The Day After the Flop: Marketing and Comms When Your Product Falls Flat
It's ten in the morning in Caserta and the air in Berto's office is thick, almost solid. It's not the Campanian heat beginning to make itself felt — it's the kind of pressure that builds when the numbers on an Excel spreadsheet stop being mere figures and start feeling like verdicts. In front of us, on the glass table reflecting the harsh glare of the fluorescent light, sits a pair of trainers that was supposed to take the market by storm. Vegetable-tanned calf leather, hand-stitched by craftsmen from three generations of the same family, a design that fused the elegance of Via Chiaia with the energy of Shoreditch. On paper, a sure-fire success. In reality, a warehouse full of stock and three sales in two months.
Berto doesn't say a word. He stares at his espresso cup — stone cold by now — with an intensity that looks like it might shatter the thing. That silence lasts thirty seconds, but it feels like hours. I can hear the hum of the air conditioning and the distant sound of traffic on Viale Carlo III. It's the sound of failure. Or rather, of what we perceive as such.
In twenty years working between Naples, London and Manchester, I've watched this scene play out dozens of times, with different people and different products. I've lived it myself — projects where I'd invested not just budget, but entire sleepless nights and pieces of my soul. The truth is that contemporary marketing is a machine programmed to celebrate only success (Read also ⟶ "marketing is afraid of getting it wrong"). The blogs are full of triumphant case studies, graphs pointing skyward like rockets, "seven secrets to selling anything." Nobody, though, writes manuals on what to do the day after a flop. Nobody explains how to look your colleagues in the eye, or how to respond to the client who's spent ten thousand euros on ads and hasn't seen a single penny come back. We've been taught to launch, to scale, to optimise. Nobody taught us how to handle the impact when the parachute doesn't open.
If you're here looking for a magic formula to avoid failure, you've come to the wrong place. Failures happen. They're statistics, they're part of the game, they're the entry fee to the world of real entrepreneurship. What we're talking about today is managing the aftermath. Because the difference between a business that folds and one that becomes a legend isn't the ability to never get things wrong — it's the quality of the communication and strategy it deploys when a product falls short of expectations.
Failure isn't a single category, and that's where our work as marketing surgeons begins. There are three distinct situations, with different causes and, crucially, completely different communication strategies. Treating them as if they were the same thing is the second mistake you could make, after the first one that got you here. Over the years I've learnt that failure is like a scar: treat it properly and it becomes part of your story and makes you stronger; ignore it and it gets infected.
I won't mince words. I'll use the concrete details of real situations, the precise figures of wasted budgets, and the exact words spoken in those silent meetings. I'll take you into my studio in Caserta, into the pubs of Salford where I've thrashed out strategies with Bobby over a pint of Boddingtons, and into the cases of major brands that made mistakes costing tens of millions of dollars. By the end of this, you won't just understand what went wrong — you'll have an operational map for turning a haemorrhage into a comeback.
Three situations, three different diagnoses
Before we get into solutions, we need to put on our diagnostic coats. Like an A&E doctor receiving a patient in critical condition, you can't administer the treatment if you haven't understood the condition. I've identified three archetypal scenarios that cover 90% of the cases where a product fails to deliver on its promises.
Scenario A — The product disappoints.
The product exists, it's on the market, but it isn't performing. Customers who've bought it aren't coming back — or worse, they're leaving reviews that read like dispatches from a warzone. There's still room to manoeuvre, but it demands a brutal honesty that few have the courage to exercise (for more on this read ⟶ "managing dissatisfied customers on social media".
Scenario B — The window has closed.
The product might be excellent, but you arrived after the wave had already receded — or you were so far ahead of the curve that nobody understood what you were on about. It's a timing problem, and time is the most precious and least controllable resource there is.
Scenario C — The premature launch.
The product wasn't ready, but it was launched anyway — out of cash-flow pressure or sheer over-optimism. Your first buyers became beta testers, whether they knew it or not. Here, communication isn't just strategy — it's applied ethics.
| Scenario | Primary cause | Key question to ask yourself |
|---|---|---|
| A: product disappoints | Mismatch between promise and reality | Is the problem how we're selling it, or what we're selling? |
| B: window closed | Timing error or misreading of trends | Are we behind the wave or too far ahead of it? |
| C: premature launch | Product immaturity | How do we handle those who trusted the incomplete version? |
Scenario A: the product disappoints
Understand before you communicate: the diagnosis nobody does
When the product isn't working, the entrepreneur's primal instinct is to find someone to blame. The agency didn't target properly, the social media manager used the wrong tone, the designer created packaging that nobody notices. The blame game, in other words. But if you genuinely want to manage failure, you need to stop looking for culprits and start looking for causes. Before you open your mouth on social media or draft a newsletter full of apologies, there's a mandatory step that almost everyone skips: understanding why the product has disappointed.
There are four fundamental diagnoses.
Product problem: the product doesn't do what it says it does, or does it badly. It's broken, it's poor quality, it's pointless. No amount of brilliant communication will save you — you need to stop and fix the thing before you say anything else.
Positioning problem: the product is brilliant, but you're selling it to the wrong people, with the wrong language, at the wrong price. You're offering a Beef Wellington to a vegan gathering.
Distribution problem: the product is right, the price is correct, but people can't actually buy it because the logistics or the site's UX are a nightmare. The customer arrives, can't find what they're after, and leaves.
Expectations problem: your marketing was too good. You promised the moon and delivered a painted rock. The disappointment stems from the gap between the narrative and the actual experience — this is the most insidious diagnosis of all, because the fault is formally yours, not the product's.
Each of these diagnoses requires a radically different communication strategy. Mixing them up is like injecting adrenaline into a patient who needs a sedative.
The case of the artisan trainers: when the problem was the language, not the product
Back to Berto's office, with the smell of tanned leather and the cold coffee. Those trainers were well made — I can vouch for that. The leather was top quality, the fit was comfortable, the price — €480 — was consistent with the cost of Campanian craftsmanship. So why weren't they selling?
I analysed the communication piece by piece. Berto, proud of his heritage, had built everything around the language of classic luxury: glossy photos in period villas, elegant but dusty serif fonts, a tone of voice that felt like it had stepped out of a 1990s antiques catalogue. The problem is that someone spending €480 on a pair of trainers today doesn't want to feel like a faded aristocrat — they want to feel part of a contemporary urban culture.
We were speaking to the wrong person in the language of another century. The diagnosis was clear: brand mismatch. Berto's heritage brand evoked ceremonies, weddings, formal occasions. The trainers evoked something else entirely, but they were communicating as if they were ceremonial loafers.
We stopped everything. We didn't bin the shoes — we binned the communication. We brought in a street photographer from Naples, took the shoes through the alleyways of the Quartieri Spagnoli and into a Shoreditch club during an electronic music night. We changed the font, switching to something brutal and contemporary. We stripped back the tone of voice, making it direct, almost raw. We built a separate site — not a new category bolted onto the existing shop, but a distinct narrative universe. Cost of the operation: roughly €3,400 covering photography, site development and new materials. In the first six weeks after the relaunch, online sales reached 67 pairs. The product was identical. The promise was finally aligned with reality.
When even the giants get positioning wrong
Don't think these mistakes are the exclusive preserve of SMEs in Caserta. The giants of global marketing have made blunders that make Berto's flop look like a minor hiccup.
Take Colgate Frozen Dinners, back in the 1980s. Colgate — the name synonymous with toothpaste and oral hygiene — decided it was a good idea to launch a range of frozen ready meals. The product itself was probably no worse than the competition. But the brand immediately evoked the taste of mint and the idea of clean teeth. Imagine eating a lasagne with your toothpaste's logo on the box. The human brain goes into meltdown. The cognitive dissonance was so powerful that the product was pulled within a matter of months, and no amount of communication could save it. The failure wasn't technical — it was semantic: they'd transferred a brand onto a territory that was its polar opposite.
And then there's New Coke, 1985. Coca-Cola decided to change its historic formula to beat Pepsi in blind taste tests. Technically the new formula won: consumers preferred it in blind tastings. But marketing had committed a grave error: it had measured taste, not the brand's identity and cultural value. Coca-Cola wasn't just a drink — it was an American icon, loaded with family memories, Christmases and baseball matches (read also ⟶ "the emotional value of a heritage brand".) Changing the formula felt like a personal betrayal. The backlash was immediate and fierce. The company pulled the product after 79 days, relaunching the original formula as "Coca-Cola Classic". What looked like the greatest failure in history became a communications triumph — but not through planning: through the ability to listen to the market, to admit the mistake without dressing it up, and to reverse course with dignity. The lesson here is this: when you get positioning wrong, pulling back isn't a defeat — it's the most respectful communicative gesture you can make towards those who put their trust in you.
For more on this read also ⟶ "the most spectacular failures in marketing history"
Operational framework — the five moves for managing Scenario A
1- Stop all promotional communication immediately.
Concretely: pause all active ad campaigns, remove the product from the featured sections of your site, and send a written message to your social media manager with a single instruction: nothing about this product until you get back in touch. Every new customer acquired right now is another disappointed customer who will fuel negative word of mouth.
2. Communicate internally before you communicate externally.
Your sales team, customer service, designers — they already know things are going badly. If you don't give them an official version, they'll invent one. Bring everyone together, in person or on a call, and say three specific things: "we have a problem", "this is the provisional diagnosis", "here's what we're doing in the next 72 hours." You don't need all the answers — you need to demonstrate that you have the situation under control.
3. Listen to the customers who've already bought it — without filters and without being defensive.
Call customers personally, send personalised non-automated emails, read every negative review as if it were free consultancy. The harshest criticism often contains the remedy. If ten people tell you the packaging is impossible to open, the problem isn't the marketing — it's the packaging. If they tell you they don't understand what it's for, the problem isn't the product — it's the communication.
4. Decide the fork: reposition or withdraw.
There's no middle ground of "let's see how it goes" — that's not a strategy, it's a slow haemorrhage that drains cash and reputation simultaneously. Either you've worked out how to change the language, target and narrative to save the product (as we did with Berto), or you need to have the courage to pull it in order to save the brand (as Coca-Cola did). The question to ask is brutally simple: with the resources I have today, can I correct enough, quickly enough, to avoid further damage? If the answer is no, get out.
5. Communicate the decision with calibrated honesty.
You don't need to post publicly in tears, nor disappear into silence. The message must be true, not exhaustive. "We've realised this product doesn't yet meet the standards we set ourselves" or "We got the way we presented this wrong, and we're fixing it." Trust is lost in a second but rebuilt by demonstrating you have the situation under control — especially, and above all, in a crisis.
Scenario B: the window has closed
The market doesn't wait
Time is the one variable that marketing cannot buy. You can have the best copywriter in the world, the most talented photographer, and an unlimited budget on Meta — but if you arrive when the party's over, or when the guests haven't turned up yet, you're out of the game. For more on this read also ⟶ "when the external context makes everything harder".
We need to distinguish two situations that look similar but require completely opposite communication approaches.
The product ahead of its time — the technology was there, the idea was sound, but the social and technological infrastructure wasn't ready. The tablets of the 1990s, the first virtual reality headsets, the smart TVs of 2008. People didn't yet feel the need for those things. Communicating in this scenario means evangelising: a costly, slow process that almost always rewards whoever comes second, not whoever comes first.
Arriving late to the wave — you showed up when the market was already saturated, the main players were established, and the consumer had already made their choice. You're the umpteenth craft beer brand in a city that already has twelve, or the umpteenth delivery service in a neighbourhood that already has five. Here the failure isn't the product's — it's a failure of strategic vision.
The difference between the two cases is crucial for communication: whoever was ahead of their time can become the narrator of their own vision ("we saw it coming before anyone else"). Whoever arrived late needs to find a genuinely differentiated angle — or position themselves honestly as an alternative with specific advantages.
Sony's Betamax and the format wars
The history of marketing is littered with distinguished casualties bearing the name "technical superiority." The most famous case is Sony's Betamax. In the 1970s, Sony launched Betamax, a video cassette format that was, objectively, superior to JVC's VHS: better video quality, more durable tape. But Sony made a market-reading error that proved fatal: Betamax cassettes had an initial maximum duration of around 60 minutes — not enough to record a full film from the television. JVC, with VHS, extended cassettes to 120 and then 240 minutes, and simultaneously built a comprehensive network of licensees that flooded the rental shops.
By the time Sony realised that the home video rental market was becoming the primary driver of video recorder sales, it was already too late: VHS had taken over the shelves, the homes, the habits. Sony's communication response remained self-referential for years — they kept talking about technical quality in a market that had already chosen on the basis of convenience and availability. Shouting "we're the best" when the consumer has already decided isn't marketing — it's irritating noise.
The case of the artisan soaps: impossible margins and a slowly closing window
A few years ago I worked with a Campanian client — let's call her Maria — who had built a small brand of artisan jewellery and leather accessories in Naples, with decent success selling perfumes. Building on that foundation, when she relocated her premises, she decided to keep the old shop going by launching a new range: soaps and creams made with extra-virgin olive oil. The product was extraordinary. Each bar of soap had the weight of a considered thought: local oil, carefully calibrated fragrances, wrapped in ivory wax paper tied with a coloured ribbon according to the scent. Holding one felt almost like a shame to use. The storytelling centred on Campanian rural tradition, the slow process of pressing the olives, the ingredient that generations of grandmothers put in everything.
We sat down together to work on it. We crafted the copy, the labelling, the packaging, the product descriptions. Everything seemed to be working. But the numbers didn't add up.
A few years ago I worked with a Campanian client — let's call her Maria — who had built a small brand of artisan jewellery and leather accessories in Naples, with decent success selling perfumes. Building on that foundation, when she relocated her premises, she decided to keep the old shop going by launching a new range: soaps and creams made with extra-virgin olive oil. The product was extraordinary. Each bar of soap had the weight of a considered thought: local oil, carefully calibrated fragrances, wrapped in ivory wax paper tied with a coloured ribbon according to the scent. Holding one felt almost like a shame to use. The storytelling centred on Campanian rural tradition, the slow process of pressing the olives, the ingredient that generations of grandmothers put in everything.
We sat down together to work on it. We crafted the copy, the labelling, the packaging, the product descriptions. Everything seemed to be working. But the numbers didn't add up.
The margins on artisan soaps are structurally low — on a range that ran from €5 for a bar of soap to €20 for a body cream, the net margin rarely exceeded 35% of sales. The shop was in a tourist location on the Campanian coast: real footfall, motivated customers, exactly the right type of audience for that product. But open seven months of the year, with twelve months of rent to pay. The maths is unforgiving: three months of high season don't cover a year of fixed costs, however well you sell. You need very high volumes to pull it off. And online — the only channel where seasonality eases — would have required an ad spend of between €600 and €800 a month for at least six consecutive months, the time needed to build an audience. Maria didn't have that available at the time.
I watched, week by week, as the window closed. Not all at once — slowly, like the smoke from a snuffed candle. The project was shelved after one season.
The reflection I take away from it is more complex than a simple "it could have been done differently." In the early weeks, when the data was starting to say what data always says with unflinching clarity, there were actually two paths.
The first: close the shop immediately, redirect the savings from the rent into a site dedicated exclusively to that range — not added as a category to the existing shop, where the soap appeared alongside a ring and a leather bag, things that had nothing to do with it — build an editorial strategy on the blog and social media centred on wellbeing and natural cosmetics, and go online with a budget of €400 a month in Meta Ads targeting a laser-focused audience: women aged 28 to 55, interested in natural cosmetics, Italian craftsmanship, sustainable wellbeing.
The second — harder to admit — was recognising that the model itself didn't work for that product. Maria had always operated in a specific and effective way: her customers, almost always from abroad, would discover the jewellery and perfumes in the shop during their holidays and continue buying online once back home. It was a formula that worked brilliantly with the perfumes, because a perfume is a narrative object — it carries with it the memory of a place, the atmosphere of a terrace overlooking the sea, the magic of a holiday. When you open it at home, you're back there.
A soap doesn't work like that. You use it, you get through it, it runs out. It doesn't evoke any place. It doesn't take you anywhere. You buy it in the shop round the corner, or on Amazon in two clicks. You choose it because it's natural, because it's gentle on the skin, because it nourishes. Transferring onto cosmetics the same emotional mechanism that had made the perfumes a success was the fundamental mistake — and no digital strategy, however well constructed, could compensate for a flawed premise.
When time is short and margins are thin, the answer isn't to do more — it's to do the one right thing with pinpoint precision. Sometimes that thing is a pivot. Sometimes it's admitting that the right product isn't right for every brand, and that the same story can't be told twice in the same way.
Operational framework — the five moves for managing Scenario B
1. Stop communicating as if the trend is still going strong.
If the market has moved on, every piece of content that speaks the language of a past trend makes you irrelevant. Do an immediate audit of your channels and remove anything that sounds dated. This isn't an aesthetic exercise — it's communicative survival.
2. Look for the residual segment.
There's almost always a long tail of the market: the discontented, the purists, those who arrive last but arrive committed. If the mass market has gone digital, speak to those who still love the analogue. If everyone is selling fast experiences, position yourself on slowness as a value. Your slowness becomes exclusivity.
3. Turn the delay into a narrative advantage.
"We waited for others to make their mistakes so we could offer you the definitive solution" isn't always untrue. Communicated with supporting data — "we spent two years studying the shortcomings of competing products before we launched" — it becomes positioning. It shifts the focus from speed to solidity. For SMEs that can't compete on the pace of large corporations, this is one of the few genuinely available communication advantages.
4. Consider the pivot before declaring defeat.
Can the product be redirected? If the olive oil cream isn't selling as a luxury retail cosmetic, could it sell as a premium corporate gift for the festive season, in packs of three or five with personalised packaging? A pivot isn't changing the product — it's changing the occasion of use in the customer's mind.
5. Set your exit threshold before you're emotionally invested in the results.
This is the hardest point for any entrepreneur, and it needs to be done with a clear head — ideally before launch or in the first few weeks. What's the figure or the date beyond which you pull the plug? Communicating a farewell with dignity — "we've decided to focus our resources on what we do best" — is always preferable to dragging out an agony that drains cash, energy and the reputation of your main brand.
Scenario C: the premature launch — when your first buyers are beta testers
A legitimate strategy, almost always poorly communicated
We live in the era of "launch and iterate." The idea is simple: get the product to market before it's perfect, gather feedback, adjust course. In many sectors — especially software, digital, and services — it's not just a legitimate strategy, it's a necessary one. The problem arises when it's applied without transparency.
There's a world of difference between saying "here's an early version — help us improve it, and in return you get early access pricing and priority on all future features" — and saying "here's the revolutionary product that will transform your life" before delivering something that crashes every five minutes.
The first approach builds a community of allies. The second builds a list of enemies with a Google Reviews account. For more on this read also ⟶ "when communication loses the customer's trust".
Tesla and the launch as an evolving platform
If there's one company that turned the early launch into a recognisable communication model, it's Tesla — at least up to a point. Buying a Tesla in the early years didn't mean buying a finished car in the traditional sense: it meant entering an ecosystem that updated, improved, and evolved. Autopilot arrived via software update after purchase. Features changed. Customers accepted — and in many cases embraced — this incompleteness because the communication contract was explicit: you're buying the future while we build it together.
The value wasn't in the "finished object" but in the "evolving experience." Turning a structural flaw — an incomplete product — into a communication strength is one of the most sophisticated operations you can pull off in marketing.
The Cybertruck and the limits of the method
That said, even the most elegant models have a breaking point. The Cybertruck launch showed where the contract with early adopters can snap. In 2019, at the reveal, the announced starting price was $39,900. By the time the first real deliveries happened in 2023, the base price had risen to $60,990 — an increase of over 52% on the original promise. Delivery dates had slipped by years. Some of the declared technical specifications didn't match independent measurements.
When the gap between the expectations generated and reality exceeds a psychological threshold — and that threshold is different for every market and every type of customer — even the most solid community starts to crack. The lesson isn't that early launches are wrong. It's that they only work if the trajectory of improvement is visible, real, and consistent with what was promised. If the promises become systematically undeliverable, it stops being marketing and becomes reputational damage management.
The ethical boundary: when "beta launch" becomes deception
Here I want to touch on a point that relates specifically to Italian entrepreneurial culture. We're brilliant at keeping up appearances. Admitting that a product isn't ready yet feels like a weakness — almost like a confession of inadequacy. So many entrepreneurs — like Berto, like Maria — tend to mask the gaps behind grand-sounding words.
But in today's market, and even more so in the British one where tolerance for a lack of transparency is close to zero, this doesn't pay off. In Manchester, if you sell something that doesn't work as promised, Bobby doesn't hang about waiting for your response — he demolishes you on Trustpilot within ten minutes, and that review stays indexed on Google for years. I've seen businesses lose 30% of their quote requests because of a handful of one-star reviews received in a difficult week.
Selling an unfinished product as if it were complete isn't a launch strategy — it's a choice with a precise ethical cost and a precise economic cost. In the short term it earns you a few sales. In the medium term it earns you a reputation that doesn't wash off easily. In Italian SMEs, where word of mouth is still the primary engine of client acquisition, being honest about a "work in progress" is the only way to survive an early launch with your brand intact.
Operational framework — the five moves for managing Scenario C
1. Define and write the early adopter contract.
Good intentions aren't enough — you need a document, a page on your site, a box during checkout, that says in plain language: what's ready today, what isn't yet, when it will be available, and what you get in return for early access. Transparency doesn't weaken the sale — it qualifies it. Someone who buys knowing it's a beta version is a prepared customer, not a victim.
2. Create a direct channel with your first buyers — not a generic support form.
A closed WhatsApp group, a dedicated weekly newsletter, an email address that replies within 24 hours. Make them feel part of an exclusive club, not numbers on a CRM list. These are your testers, your public defenders, your future evangelists — if you treat them as such.
3. Update regularly, even when you have no major news.
The perception of movement is almost as valuable as movement itself. "This week we fixed the checkout bug on mobile and added feature X that you'd asked for" is communication worth more than three promotional posts. It demonstrates that you're listening, it demonstrates progress, it keeps trust alive.
4. Compensate proactively, not reactively.
If you identify a serious problem, don't wait for the customer to complain. Contact them first. "We've identified an issue with products made between 10 and 20 March. If you purchased during that period, here's what we're offering you." The cost of this gesture — a refund, a discount, a free upgrade — is a fraction of the cost of a reputational crisis that forces you to do it anyway, but defensively.
5. Don't use early adopters as a communication shield.
Avoid phrases like "we've received enthusiastic feedback from our first users" if you know that half of them are reporting problems. This dissonance between the public narrative and the private experience of your customers is the quickest way to lose credibility permanently. Your early adopters have eyes, they have social media accounts, they talk to each other.
The STOP-DIAGNOSE-COMMUNICATE Protocol
We've explored the three scenarios and analysed the cases of Berto, Maria, Sony and Tesla. Now it's time to join the dots. Managing failure isn't a matter of brilliance — it's a matter of method. Here's the protocol I've been using for years with clients who find themselves in these situations.
STOP — 24 hours of operational silence.
It sounds obvious, but it's the hardest thing to do. When things go badly, adrenaline pushes you towards reactive action: responding to negative comments, launching a special offer, changing the site, sending an apology newsletter. Stop. Every decision made in a state of panic or deep disappointment is almost certainly the wrong one. You're not wasting time — you're buying clarity. During the 24-hour stop, gather the data, talk to your sales team, read the reviews, and — if you can — go for a walk. The hum of the air conditioning in Berto's office wasn't helping anyone think straight.
DIAGNOSE — Compare data against expectations.
With the diagnosis in hand, you identify which of the three scenarios you're actually in. Don't fool yourself: if the product is poor quality, don't call it an "early launch" to feel less culpable. If you're late to the market, don't call it a "positioning mismatch" to avoid admitting a failure of strategic vision. The truth — even the uncomfortable truth — is the only solid foundation for a comeback.
COMMUNICATE — Apply the specific framework.
Only now, with the diagnosis confirmed by data, do you open your mouth. You apply the framework for your specific scenario, not someone else's. Not the solution you read on an American blog, not the one your competitor used last year. Yours.
| Phase | Key action | Objective |
|---|---|---|
| STOP | 24 hours of operational silence | Remove emotion from strategy |
| DIAGNOSE | Compare data against expectations | Identify the real scenario (A, B or C) |
| COMMUNICATE | Apply the specific framework | Rebuild trust with transparency and value |
What you don't say matters as much as what you do
Let's close with a catalogue of the most common communication errors in moments of crisis. These phrases sound professional. They're poison.
"We are assessing the situation."
It's the corporate version of "I don't know what to do." It communicates nothing — it only signals helplessness. Anyone who reads it — customer, supplier, colleague — automatically interprets it as: nobody is in control.
"Results have fallen short of our expectations."
Bureaucratic language that offloads blame onto an abstract entity. Customers didn't buy expectations — they bought a product that doesn't work. The distance between the words and the reality is precisely what destroys trust.
"The market wasn't ready."
It might even be true. But said like that, without supporting argument, it sounds like an excuse. And it alienates everyone who's already bought: you're implicitly telling them that whoever purchased belongs to an immature market. That's not exactly the message you want to send to your best customers.
"We are working to improve."
Without a precise timeline, without details about what's being improved and how, this phrase is hot air. It's worth less than nothing. It only becomes credible if followed by: "and in three weeks we'll send you an update with the concrete results."
Silence.
It's always the worst form of communication, because it leaves room for customers' imaginations to run wild. And in moments of crisis, the imagination tends invariably towards the worst. I've seen businesses lose contracts not because they'd done something irreparable, but because they'd gone quiet for ten days without a word.
The Shoreditch Rule, learnt during an evening in a pub in East London while watching the trams at night through the window and thinking about Bobby's situation: in the UK, tolerance for corporate silence is zero. The British customer — Bobby's customer in Manchester, the one who trusted him and ended up with a product that didn't work as promised — doesn't wait for him to get in touch. They look the brand up on Trustpilot, on Reddit, on X, and what they write determines what everyone else will find. For years. In Caserta it works differently, but the direction is the same: digital word of mouth has a long memory.
Conclusion
Let's go back for a moment to that morning in Caserta. Berto finally looked up from his espresso cup. He took a deep breath and said: "Umberto, we got everything wrong, didn't we?" In that question was the end of one version of the story and the beginning of another. It wasn't the end of the business — it was the turning point.
We applied the protocol. We stopped. We made the diagnosis — a positioning problem, not a product problem. We changed the visuals, shifted the target, rebuilt the narrative piece by piece. Three months later, those trainers were Berto's flagship product.
The final thesis is simple but radical: the businesses that survive failure aren't the ones that never get things wrong. Those only exist in marketing fairy tales and on the LinkedIn profiles of keynote gurus. The businesses that endure are those that, in the moment they stumble, stop improvising and start thinking. Communication in failure isn't about papering over the cracks and hoping nobody notices. It's high-level communication — perhaps the most complex a professional can ever have to manage — the moment when you demonstrate that behind the logo, the packaging and the social media campaigns there's an intelligence capable of learning and an ethic capable of respecting those who placed their trust in you.
Don't be afraid of your next product flopping. Be afraid of not having a strategy to manage it. Be afraid of reacting with ego instead of data. Be afraid of silence.
The market forgives an honest, well-managed mistake far more readily than it forgives a clever ruse gone wrong. I've seen it. I've lived it. And every time I've had to sit down at that table with the cold coffee, I've understood a little better what it really means to do this work. For more on this read also ⟶ "being remembered matters more than being noticed"
Now imagine you're in that silent meeting tomorrow morning. The numbers are grim, your most trusted colleague is looking at you waiting for a signal. Do you already know what your first move would be?
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the three main scenarios of marketing failure?
Scenario A — The product disappoints expectations: the product exists and is on the market, but it underperforms. Customers do not return or leave negative reviews. There is still room to manoeuvre through brutal honesty about the issue (product flaws, incorrect positioning, failed distribution, or expectations set far too high). Scenario B — The timing window has closed: the product is excellent, but you arrived after the wave had already receded, or before anyone understood what you were talking about. The issue is timing, not the product itself. Scenario C — Premature launch: the product was not ready, but it was launched anyway due to cash-flow pressure or excessive optimism. The first buyers became beta testers. Each scenario requires a radically different diagnosis and communication strategy.
How can I understand whether the real problem is the product or the positioning?
You need a four-point diagnosis: Product problem — the product does not do what it claims, it is broken, or it is poor quality. Positioning problem — the product is excellent, but you are selling it to the wrong people, using the wrong language, at the wrong price. Distribution problem — the product is correct, but people cannot buy it because of logistical or UX issues. Expectation problem — the marketing was too effective and you promised the moon while delivering a painted stone. The most insidious diagnosis is the last one: formally, the fault is yours, not the product’s. To understand which case applies to you, listen carefully to customers who have already bought, without filtering or defending yourself.
When a product is not working, should I publish a public apology immediately?
No — not immediately. First, stop. Enter a 24-hour operational silence period. Every decision made in panic is almost certainly wrong. During that time, pause all active advertising campaigns, remove the product from featured sections, communicate internally with your team (“we have a problem, this is the provisional diagnosis, and this is what we will do over the next 72 hours”), and listen deeply to customers who have already purchased. Only afterwards should you communicate with calibrated honesty: “We have realised this product does not yet meet the standards we set for ourselves” or “We presented this in the wrong way, and we are correcting it.” Trust is lost in seconds, but rebuilt by demonstrating control of the situation — even during a crisis.
Was Berto’s sneaker case a product problem or a communication problem?
It was a radical communication problem — what I call a “brand mismatch”. The trainers were well made, the leather was premium quality, and the €480 price reflected the craftsmanship from Campania. The issue was that Berto had built the entire communication strategy around traditional luxury language — polished photographs in historic villas, dusty serif fonts, a tone resembling 1990s antique catalogues — whereas someone spending €480 on trainers today wants to feel connected to a contemporary urban culture. We were speaking to the wrong person using the language of another century. The solution was not to throw away the shoes, but to throw away the communication: street photography between the Spanish Quarters and Shoreditch, brutalist contemporary typography, and a separate website with a distinct narrative universe. In the first six weeks after the relaunch: 67 pairs sold. Identical product. A promise finally aligned with reality.
How do I manage Scenario B when the market has already overtaken me?
You must distinguish between two situations: A product ahead of the market — the technology existed, the idea was correct, but the social infrastructure was not ready. In this case, you need evangelisation (slow, expensive, and usually rewarding the second entrant rather than the pioneer). Late to the wave — you arrived after saturation. Here you must identify a residual segment (people who still love analogue while everyone else races towards digital, or those who arrive late but fully convinced). Transform the delay into a narrative advantage: “We waited for others to make their mistakes” (supported by data). Consider a pivot: can the product be repositioned? An olive oil cream that fails as a cosmetic may succeed as a premium corporate gift. Finally, define an exit threshold before emotions take over: what amount of money or deadline determines when you stop?
Was Colgate Frozen Dinners really a genuine marketing disaster?
Yes. In the 1980s, Colgate — synonymous with toothpaste and oral hygiene — launched a range of frozen ready meals. The product itself was probably no worse than competitors’ offerings, but the brand immediately evoked the taste of menthol and the sensation of clean teeth. Imagine eating a lasagne with your toothpaste logo on the packaging: the human brain short-circuits because of cognitive dissonance. The product was withdrawn within months, and communication could not save it. The failure was not technological, but semantic: they transferred a brand into a territory that represented its exact opposite.
How do I manage Scenario C (premature launch) without losing credibility?
The difference is enormous between saying “here is a preliminary version, help us improve it, and in return you receive early access and priority on future features” — and saying “here is the revolutionary product” before delivering something unstable. The first approach creates allies. The second creates enemies with Google Reviews accounts. In Scenario C, you must: 1) Define and document the early-adopter agreement (what is ready, what is not, timelines, and benefits), 2) Create a direct communication channel with the first buyers (private WhatsApp group, weekly newsletter, or email replies within 24 hours), 3) Provide updates regularly even when there is no spectacular news, 4) Offer proactive compensation — do not wait for complaints; contact customers yourself when you identify a problem, 5) Never use early adopters as a shield — avoid phrases such as “enthusiastic feedback” when half of them are reporting issues. Radical transparency is the only way to survive a premature launch with your brand intact.
Did Tesla manage the Cybertruck’s premature launch well?
Tesla invented the concept of the launch as an evolving platform — buying a car no longer meant buying a finished object, but entering an ecosystem that evolved through software updates. Autopilot arrived after purchase, features changed continuously. Customers accepted this incompleteness because the communication contract was explicit. However, the Cybertruck demonstrated where the contract breaks down: in 2019 the price was $39,900, while by 2023 the base model cost $60,990 (a 52% increase), delivery dates had slipped by years, and performance promises no longer matched independent testing. The gap between expectation and reality exceeded the psychological threshold. The lesson: premature launches only work if the trajectory of improvement is visible, genuine, and aligned with what was promised. Once promises become systematically unattainable, it stops being marketing and becomes reputational damage control.
What is the STOP–DIAGNOSE–COMMUNICATE protocol?
STOP — 24 hours of operational silence: when things go wrong, adrenaline pushes you towards reactive action. Stop. Every decision made in panic is wrong. You are not wasting time; you are gaining clarity. DIAGNOSE — Compare data against expectations: with the diagnosis in hand, identify which of the three scenarios you are facing (A, B, or C). Do not lie to yourself — if the product is poor, do not call it a “premature launch”. COMMUNICATE — Apply the specific framework: only now, with a diagnosis confirmed by data, apply the framework suited to your scenario, not someone else’s. The difference between a company that collapses and one that becomes legendary is not the ability to avoid mistakes forever, but the quality of its strategic communication when the parachute fails to open.
Which phrases should I absolutely avoid when communicating failure?
“We are evaluating the situation” — the corporate equivalent of “we do not know what to do”, communicating helplessness. “The results are below our expectations” — bureaucratic language that alienates already disappointed customers. “The market was not ready” — without supporting arguments, it sounds like an excuse and insults those who already bought (are they part of an immature market?). “We are working to improve” — without a specific timeline, it is meaningless. It only becomes credible when paired with something like “in three weeks we will send you an update with concrete results.” Silence — leaves space for customers’ imagination, which almost always drifts towards the worst-case scenario. I have seen businesses lose contracts not because of irreparable mistakes, but because they disappeared for ten days without saying a word. In the UK, tolerance for corporate silence is effectively zero.
How does the management of failure differ between Italy and the UK?
In Italy (and particularly in Campania), customers like Berto want to feel an authentic human relationship: a voice telling them “I’m here”, someone who knows their name and speaks person-to-person. The reaction is emotional. In the British market, customers like Bobby want to see process: a structured email with an incident report, steps towards resolution, and a precise timeline. They do not want you to be their friend; they want you to be a professional with a clear methodology. Two different cultures, one common root: both want to be treated like intelligent human beings. But tolerance for ambiguity differs radically. In the UK, tolerance for corporate silence is zero. British customers do not wait for you to contact them: they search for the brand on Trustpilot, Reddit, and X. What they write determines what everyone else will find for years to come.
By accepting you will be accessing a service provided by a third-party external to https://insightadv.it/
IT
EN 

















































Comments