The lying narrator: a guide to the unreliable narrator
The Granatello harbour in Portici reeks, at this hour, of cold smoke, diesel from the fishing boats and that thick salt tang that clings to your skin. A thin wind was cutting at my ankles and creeping up under my jacket. I was sat on a frozen iron bollard, rereading the first draft of Michele's novel — a client from Caserta who fixes tractors for a living and writes in the evenings. Three hundred pages in a seemingly flawless first person. And yet something was off. Every time the protagonist described the end of his marriage, the words flowed too smoothly, too cleanly.
Watching the fishermen haul in their nets, it clicked. The character wasn't telling the story. He was defending himself before an invisible court. He was lying to the reader, but it wasn't the character's fault — it was Michele's, because he hadn't noticed. He'd built an unwitting liar, believing all the while he was writing an objective account.
What an unreliable narrator actually is (and what it isn't)
Let's get a proper, solid technical definition on the table, without the academic waffle. The term "unreliable narrator" was coined by the American critic Wayne Booth in his essay The Rhetoric of Fiction (1961), to describe a narrating voice whose reading of events deviates structurally from the objective reality of the story — a deviation the author has planned deliberately, to produce an emotional or cognitive effect in the reader.
There's a common misunderstanding that sinks a lot of drafts. An unreliable narrator isn't simply a character who doesn't know everything. It isn't a limited point of view. If your protagonist is shut in a room and doesn't know it's chucking it down outside, that's logistical ignorance, not unreliability.
True unreliability plays out in the gap between fact and interpretation. In my experience, the whole narrative contract hinges on this: the reader agrees to be deceived only if they sense the deception follows precise rules. We're not palming cards under the table for an easy win. We're inviting the reader into a deeper game.
I've written before about how point of view isn't a simple technique but a political decision (Point of view isn't a technique: it's a political decision), and about the intricate business of managing the author's presence through the art of disappearing. With the unreliable narrator, the voice doesn't disappear at all: it takes centre stage, fills the frame, but does so whilst showing its own cracks.
The five technical types
To get a proper handle on this tool, you need a clear taxonomy. In the Western literary tradition, unreliability manifests chiefly through five technical structures. I'll go through them one by one, with a real example for each — because a mechanism without a name and a title stays an abstraction fit only for a lecture hall, and here we want to get our hands dirty.
The naïve narrator
Here the gap comes from the immaturity or innocence of the speaker. The narrator records the facts with pinpoint precision but lacks the cultural, cognitive or emotional tools to decode them. The reader understands far sooner, and far better, than the character on the page.
The example I always use in workshops is Scout Finch, the narrating voice of Harper Lee's To Kill a Mockingbird. Scout describes the racial tensions and trials of the Deep South with photographic precision, but sees them through the eyes of a child who can't grasp their true weight. The dramatic force comes precisely from that contrast: we understand the horror, she just registers curious facts.
The lying narrator
This is the riskiest and most geometric case. The narrator knows perfectly well how things went, but omits, shifts dates, alters details to build a visual or moral alibi. They've got a personal stake in manipulating the reader.
The most surgical example is Amy Dunne in Gillian Flynn's Gone Girl: her diary, which the reader takes as genuine for half the novel, turns out to be a calculated construction designed to frame her husband. Flynn doesn't cheat — she scatters the cracks in that too-perfect prose with the patience of a goldsmith.
The psychologically compromised narrator
Here perception of reality is warped by deep trauma, an obsession, or a psychiatric condition that distorts space and time. There's no deliberate intent to deceive as with the liar: there's a biological or emotional inability to see the world as it is, and often the reader can't establish with any certainty what actually happened and what didn't.
The textbook case is Patrick Bateman in Bret Easton Ellis's American Psycho: the prose becomes saturated with a maniacal obsession over brands, restaurants, business cards, whilst violent events are recounted in exactly the same flat tone — to the point where the reader never quite knows whether they're reading a genuine confession or a delusion. It's a different type from the self-deception we'll come to shortly: Bateman doesn't hide behind propriety, his voice openly collapses under the weight of his own pathology.
The self-deceiving narrator
Unlike the liar, this figure genuinely believes their own version of events. They lie to themselves to survive pain, failure or shame. It's one of the most human and literarily rich types out there.
The perfect example, and fittingly a British one, is Stevens, the butler protagonist of Kazuo Ishiguro's The Remains of the Day. Stevens recounts his life in service as an absolute choice of professional dignity, whilst every page lets slip — never stated outright, never shouted — a love never lived and a moral complicity with a master compromised by his Nazi sympathies. Ishiguro never has Stevens say "I got it wrong": he lets the reader work it out through what Stevens chooses not to see.
The narrator with incomplete knowledge (discrepant awareness)
The distortion here stems from limited or fragmented access to the facts, often combined with temporary states of impairment. The narrative proceeds in fits and starts, and the tension builds in the gaps the reader has to fill in themselves.
A prime example: Paula Hawkins's The Girl on the Train, where the protagonist Rachel views the world through gaps of alcoholic memory, and the truth only emerges by weighing her version against two other narrating voices, each holding just a splinter of the story.
How to signal unreliability without spelling it out
The golden rule is absolute: the reader must be able to doubt before they discover. If the twist comes out of nowhere, with no clues scattered along the way, you're not a good writer — you're just a fairground conjuror hiding the ace up your sleeve.
To make the mechanism work you need microscopic clues, a slow and methodical seeding.
Minimal timeline inconsistencies.
The narrator says he was at home resting on Wednesday, but two chapters later recalls the smell of rain caught while walking into town that very afternoon. These shouldn't be glaring errors that shatter the coherence of the narrative world, but small cracks in the memory.
The reactions of secondary characters.
This is the most effective barometer. If the protagonist describes himself as a calm, measured, easy-going man, but every time he speaks to a waiter or his wife, they flinch, show irritation, or stare at the floor in silence, the reader understands the reflection in the mirror is false.
A vocabulary that gives the game away.
Use words too precise for a character who claims not to remember a scene well. If you say you've blocked out the trauma of a crash but then describe with surgical exactness the calibre of the bolts on the other car's number plate, you're saying too much.
Protesting too much. A narrator who insists, unprompted and one time too many, that they're calm, honest or disinterested is doing the exact opposite of what they claim. "I'm not jealous. I've never been jealous, not once in my life" written twice in the same chapter carries more weight than any full-blown scene: the reader starts counting how many times a quality gets claimed rather than shown, and each repetition is a brick pulled out of the narrator's credibility, not added to it.
The mismatch between the rhythm of the prose and the emotional content. A narrator who recounts a devastating event in short sentences, almost like a police report, then spends two pages on the brand of a waiter's shoes, is signalling a dissociation — exactly the mechanism that makes Patrick Bateman so unsettling in American Psycho: the descriptive obsession with the trivial and the dryness over the essential are, together, proof that something in the narrating voice has broken.
The unreliable narrator works exactly like the fishmonger at Granatello harbour who swears, looking you a touch too straight in the eye, that the fish was hauled up an hour ago. You don't look at his face; you look at the texture of the mullet's eye and the sheen of its gills. The clues are in the text, not in the speaker's claims.
Not every signalling technique works the same way across all five types outlined above. Here's the matrix I use during editing to steer the choice:
| Narrator type | Most effective signalling technique |
|---|---|
| Naïve narrator | Reactions of secondary characters — the only way to let the reader grasp what the narrator can't work out alone |
| Lying narrator | Minimal timeline inconsistencies — small calendar cracks that deliberate omission leaves exposed |
| Psychologically compromised narrator | Mismatch between prose rhythm and emotional content — the language itself shows the fracture |
| Self-deceiving narrator | Protesting too much — the insistence on their own rectitude is the symptom of what's repressed |
| Narrator with incomplete knowledge | Vocabulary that gives the game away — sudden precision at a point of declared uncertain memory reveals what the narrator really knows |
The mistakes that break the narrative contract
Building this structure demands geometric rigour. When the machine jams, the text becomes unreadable. Let me show you what happens when control of the page slips.
| Structural error | Effect on the text |
|---|---|
| The lie serves only the plot, not the character | The character becomes a flat puppet; the reader feels stitched up by the author |
| Revealing the deception too soon, out of fear the reader won't get it | The tension collapses at once; the following pages become a slow, over-explained slog |
| Revealing it too late, in the final line, with no clues scattered beforehand | It kills the value of a reread; the novel is reduced to a cheap trick |
An illuminating historical case is the critical row that broke out around Agatha Christie's The Murder of Roger Ackroyd (1926). At the time of publication, a section of the public and critics judged the solution "unfair" to the reader, accusing the author of having broken the rules of fair play in the classic detective novel.
The other half of the critics hailed it a masterpiece. Why? Because on a second reading, every single clue was exactly where it should be, in plain sight, camouflaged within the folds of ordinary everyday description. The line between a stroke of genius and a cheap swindle lies solely in the surgical precision of the technical execution — not in the premise.
When the deception leaves the novel: the Bioscalin case
This principle doesn't only apply to fiction. It applies, with far more concrete consequences, to persuasive writing too. In 2011 the Italian Competition Authority fined the Bioscalin advertising campaign €150,000 (read the story here), the Giuliani anti-hair-loss product found guilty of claiming a 79.9% reduction in hair loss and a 57.8% increase in hair diameter without stating that the trial had been carried out on a sample of just 40 people, who moreover suffered from a very specific form of baldness. The narrating voice — the advert's voiceover — wasn't lying about any single figure, but was building, through selective omission, an unreliable narrator in the most technical sense of the term: a point of view that chooses what to show in order to produce a conclusion the full facts wouldn't support.
Not all unreliability in advertising is dodgy, mind. When Old Spice launched its famous "The Man Your Man Could Smell Like" campaign in 2010, it built a blatantly hyperbolic testimonial-narrator, promising in a single tracking shot to be everywhere, to possess everything, to transform in an instant. Not a single viewer believes a word that narrator says — and that's precisely the deal: unreliability declared openly, theatrically, winking at the audience rather than deceiving them, becomes entertainment and builds trust in the brand rather than undermining it. The difference between Bioscalin and Old Spice isn't the technique: it's the honesty of the contract with whoever's watching.
Practical application: a three-step exercise
If you fancy testing this technique on your own text, here's a proper rigid framework — the one I often use during studio editing sessions, the last time being a late-summer afternoon, sat at a little table under the arcades opposite the Criminal Court in Santa Maria Capua Vetere, shadows stretching across the cobbles as I read through another client's novel page by page with him. You don't need grand abstractions; you need paper, a pen, and an absolute grip on the facts.
📦 Working box — the unreliable narrator matrix
- The objective truth matrix. Before writing a single line of the chapter, write a cold, neutral third-person account of what actually happened in the scene. Who spoke first? Who hit whom? What time was it? This sheet is for you alone: it'll never make it into the final text.
- Choosing the distorting filter. Pick one of the five types outlined above. Pin down exactly why the character needs to alter that reality: are they protecting themselves from pain? Do they want to appear better than they are? Is their perception skewed by their senses or by a substance?
- The mirror-image rewrite. Rewrite the scene in the first person using the chosen filter. As you do it, drop in exactly three physical clues that give the lie to the narrator's voice — a reflection in a window, a wrong detail about the time, ten seconds of awkward silence from the other person.
The bookshop in the Northern Quarter: a century's doubt ahead of us
March 2025. A Wednesday afternoon in Manchester's Northern Quarter, that stretch of old textile warehouses turned into secondhand bookshops and independent coffee spots. The usual thin rain was falling, the kind that never announces itself here — it just starts. I'd nipped into a secondhand bookshop as narrow as a corridor, shelves right up to the ceiling, to kill an hour before a photoshoot. The bookseller — a chap in his sixties with a threadbare jumper worn at the elbows — spotted me flicking through a yellowed edition and said, without my having asked a thing: "If you're after the unreliable narrator before the English had a name for it, this is your book."
He put Ford Madox Ford's The Good Soldier into my hands, published in 1915. The opening line runs, roughly: this is the saddest story I have ever heard. The narrator, John Dowell, repeats it like a mantra, and across three hundred pages builds up and dismantles his own version of events in front of the reader, admitting more than once that he himself doesn't understand what really happened in his marriage. He's no liar like Amy Dunne, nor does he have Stevens's paralysing courtesy: he's a narrator who openly confesses his own inability to tell a reliable story — an honesty about dishonesty we'd still call by another name a century on.
The bookseller told me that novel had unsettled the critics of its day just as much as The Murder of Roger Ackroyd unsettled crime readers a decade later: the English tradition institutionalised doubt about its own narrating voice a century ahead of the game, as a declared literary device, not just as emotional reticence between characters — something I'd already seen up close myself, months earlier, in an office on City Road, when Bobby told me my copy "was fine" while folding the page with a pressure that said the exact opposite (How to write dialogue that doesn't tell the truth). There, the lie lived between two people in the same room. Here, it lives between the author and whoever's holding the book — and that's a step up a level, not a repeat of the same trick.
The Italian tradition, when it does build an unreliable narrator — I'm thinking of historical crime fiction and the rawest strand of our realist writing — rarely does so through declared doubt in the way Ford Madox Ford does. It does it through accumulation: the lying voice seeks the reader's emotional complicity, grabs them by the lapel in an alley in the Spanish Quarter or on a bench along Naples' seafront, and justifies itself until you lose track of what's true.
Understanding this historical and cultural positioning lets you choose which tool to build your narrator with: doubt declared from the first line, as with Ford Madox Ford, or the confession that arrives through sheer exhaustion, as in the Italian tradition.
I firmly believe one thing, and my experience on the ground bears it out every day: the perfectly honest, objective and balanced first-person narrator doesn't exist. It's a textbook invention that strips the page of depth. Writing a first person while pretending it's a neutral camera is literature's real big lie.
Every human being who speaks up to tell their own story selects, cuts, stitches together and shields their own scars. Embracing the unreliability of point of view is simply an act of intellectual honesty towards real life. Make your voice partial, make it fragile, make it biased. It's the only way to make it unforgettable.
Frequently Asked Questions
What exactly is an unreliable narrator?
It's a narrating voice whose version of events departs, deliberately on the author's part, from the objective reality of the story. The term was coined by the critic Wayne Booth in 1961. It shouldn't be confused with a simply limited point of view or a narrator who doesn't know everything: unreliability arises from a gap between fact and interpretation, not from a lack of information.
Is an unreliable narrator the same thing as a first-person narrator?
No. You can write in the first person in a perfectly reliable way, and you can build an unreliable narrator even in limited third person. Unreliability is a technical choice about the gap between what the narrator states and what the text lets the reader infer, regardless of the grammatical person used.
Can the unreliable narrator be used outside crime or thriller genres?
Yes, and it's actually where it works best. Some of the technique's most powerful examples belong to pure literary fiction, such as Kazuo Ishiguro's "The Remains of the Day", where there's no mystery to solve at all, just an entire novel built on the protagonist's self-deception.
How do I stop the reader feeling "conned" once they twig the deception?
The principle is: scatter verifiable clues before the reveal, not after. If, rereading the text from the start, every clue holds up and was already there, the reader feels satisfaction. If the clues weren't there, all they feel is that the author, not the character, has deceived them.
Can the unreliable narrator be used in persuasive or advertising writing too?
With great care. A narrating voice that's openly hyperbolic and theatrical, as in the 2010 Old Spice campaign, can work as entertainment because the audience knows they're not meant to believe it. Hidden unreliability presented as objective fact, as in the Bioscalin case fined by the Italian Competition Authority in 2011, is misleading advertising, not a narrative technique.
What's the most common mistake made by first-timers writing an unreliable narrator?
Building the lie to serve the plot rather than the character. If the narrator only lies because the script demands it, the reader spots the artifice. The lie needs to spring from a coherent psychological motivation: shame, self-protection, fear, self-deception.
Is there a difference between the British and Italian traditions in building an unreliable narrator?
In my experience, yes: the British school tends to work by subtraction and ellipsis, hiding the deception behind a facade of composure. The Italian tradition, more confessional, works by accumulation: the narrator lies through excess of words and justification, chasing the reader's emotional complicity.
By accepting you will be accessing a service provided by a third-party external to https://insightadv.it/
IT
EN 
















































Comments