20 minutes reading time (4075 words)

Google Business Profile: your best salesperson costs you nothing

Umberto Mazza, creative director at Insight ADV, shows Google Business Profile on a smartphone in an alley in the historic centre of Naples

Let me tell you a story that begins with the smell of solder and tin in a repair workshop in Portici, and ends among the red bricks of a pub in Hackney, east London. Two very different worlds, I know — but the thread connecting them is tighter than you might think.

Let's start with Antonio. Antonio has run a domestic appliance repair centre in Portici for over twenty years. The man's a wizard: he hears a washing machine and can tell you straightaway whether it's the belt or the bearing. He's got three technicians, a steady stream of work. And yet he spends around €800 a month on Google Ads because — his words — "if I don't pay, the phone doesn't ring".

His Google Business Profile exists, sure, but it's a no man's land. Google auto-generated it back in 2018. The last photo? His old Fiat Scudo van, scrapped three years ago. Opening hours? Saturday shows as closed, but he's there grafting away until 1pm. Reviews? Twelve in total, a few of them scathing about delays he never bothered to explain — and never responded to. "Umberto, I haven't got time for this digital nonsense," he'd tell me over a bitter espresso at the bar below his workshop.

Two hundred metres away is Sergio. Same trade, five years in business. Advertising budget: zero. And yet his van is constantly on the road. His GBP is a gem: updated every week, ninety-four reviews averaging 4.9 stars. He replies to everyone — even the ones moaning about a part that arrived late. In his FAQ section, he's written it plain as day: "Same-day repairs? Yes, if you call before 10am for common faults." When a householder in Portici searches "washing machine repair near me", Sergio comes up first. Antonio doesn't exist.

💬 My own experience

When I showed Antonio the data from his profile — this was September 2024, sitting in his workshop in Portici, with the background noise of a dismantled spin drum — the first thing he said was: "but are these my customers?". Yes. Thirty-seven people a month had searched "appliance repair Portici" and had landed on his listing. Four had clicked to call. The other thirty-three had gone to Sergio. At that point the coffee went cold on the workbench, and neither of us said a word for a good thirty seconds.

Different scene. James has a bistro in Hackney. He's sunk thousands of pounds into a cracking website. But his GBP is the basic version, set up out of habit and left to gather dust. On a rainy Tuesday evening, a couple of tourists in Shoreditch search "best gastropub Hackney" on Google Maps. They find his competitor, The Rusty Anchor, which has just uploaded a photo of a freshly pulled Sunday Roast. James has an empty restaurant; his neighbour has a waiting list.

The question we need to be asking in 2026 isn't how much marketing costs — it's how much your neglected GBP listing is already costing you.

📊 Some context

  • According to Google data from 2024, around 46% of searches on Google have local intent. (Source: cited in various local marketing reports, including Boostigo and AIOSEO).
  • According to Google/Ipsos data reported by Think with Google, 76% of people who carry out a local search on a smartphone visit a physical business within 24 hours.
  • Industry estimates suggest that around 60% of Italian SMEs have incomplete or abandoned Google Business Profile listings, which directly undermines their local visibility and lead generation.

It's like having a brilliant salesperson working for you for free, then slapping tape over their mouth and hiding them in a cupboard. Back home in Naples, my grandmother used to say "ha da passà a nuttata" — the night will pass, better times will come. But this particular night won't pass unless you switch on the digital light.

What Google Business Profile actually is in 2026

It's not just a listing any more. It's your real homepage.

Forget the old idea of a "digital phone directory". In 2026, GBP is where purchasing decisions are made. People don't go to your website to find out who you are — they look at the panel that appears on Google Search or Maps. If they don't find what they're after there, your site — however lovely it is — will never get a look-in.

GBP (which plenty of people still call by the old name, Google My Business) is now the beating heart of local AI Overviews. When Google's AI answers a local query along the lines of "where can I find a carpenter in Caserta who restores antique furniture?", it doesn't trawl the entire web. It draws directly from the structured data and reviews within GBP profiles.

🔎 A finding that changes everything

BrightLocal (2025) documented how AI Overviews have begun citing GBP listing content verbatim in generated responses: descriptions such as "a reputation for winning big" or "majority female-owned" were pulled directly from profiles and reproduced in the AI Overview. Source: BrightLocal, AI & Google Business Profile, October 2025

The engine of local visibility is what's known as the Local Pack: that panel showing the top three local businesses at the head of the results. Around 44% of clicks on Google for local searches go to one of those three results, compared with 29% for organic results (a figure attributed to Moz, 2021, and cited in the company's official communications and industry summaries). Coming fourth is, for all practical purposes, being invisible.

Google evaluates GBP listings on three core ranking factors:

  • Relevance: how closely your category and description match the search query. This is the most controllable signal.
  • Distance: how physically close you are to the user. Not easy to change, but address accuracy matters.
  • Prominence: how many reviews you have, your rating, and how often you update your listing. This is where the real competition plays out.

In Naples and Caserta, digital prominence is how word-of-mouth scales up. In London, where the density of businesses is fierce, relevance is the only lifeline against the big brands. Your GBP is the bridge between these two realities.

The profile that's losing you customers: the most common mistakes

This isn't an academic lecture. It's a diagnosis. We're heading straight into the digital A&E.

Comparison between an abandoned and an optimised Google Business Profile listing on a smartphone, showing a clear difference in reviews and photos

1. Wrong or out-of-date opening hours

The original sin. On Saturday morning, three potential customers searched "appliance repair" on their phones. Google showed Antonio's listing with a red "Closed" label. Those customers went to Sergio. Antonio was right there in his workshop, shutter up, coffee on the bench.

As far as Google was concerned, he didn't exist. Typo that took 30 seconds to make. Cost: real customers, every single week.

In London, James forgot to add his Thursday happy hour. Customers turned up, found it rammed, and left. One-star review. Hundreds of pounds in lost revenue.

2. No photos — or photos from 2019

According to the Birdeye 2024 report, 82% of consumers check Google Business listings before visiting a business, and 64% do an online search before buying in store. The images on your listing matter enormously: a GBP with real, up-to-date photos conveys far more trust and converts far better.

In 2026, Google uses AI to analyse the visual content of uploaded images. Upload a photo of a dismantled washing machine and Google "understands" that you're a repairer, and rewards you in related searches. Photos aren't decoration. They're data.

3. Reviews left unanswered

Not responding to a review is like turning your back on a customer who's talking to you in the shop. If the review is positive, a personalised thank-you strengthens the relationship. If it's negative, a professional response is your best marketing move: people reading it won't judge you for the mistake — they'll judge you on how you handle it.

Worth noting: to appear in Google's local AI Overviews, your profile needs a minimum rating of 4.5/5 and a good number of reviews with detailed written content (source: Tready, Local SEO 2026). Silence in your reviews drags down your rating. A low rating locks you out of AI Overviews. AI Overviews are where the customers go. Do the maths.

4. Wrong or overly generic primary category

Registering as "Commercial activity" is like turning up to a wedding in your pyjamas: you're there, but completely out of place. If you're an electrician, say "Electrician". If you install smart home systems, add it under secondary categories. Your category is the strongest signal you send to the algorithm.

5. The zombie listing

No posts, no updates for six months, no FAQ. Google reads the silence as inactivity and drops your visibility. Consistency beats perfection. You don't need to write an essay: one photo a week or a brief post about a service is more than enough.

How to optimise your GBP listing, step by step

Right, let's roll up our sleeves. This is the framework I use with Insight ADV clients, adapted for both the Campania market and the London one.

Step 1 — Claim and verify

Many businesses in Naples and Caserta have zombie listings auto-generated by Google that nobody has ever claimed. Head to business.google.com, search for your business and start the verification process. These days Google often requires a video call or a short clip of your premises to confirm your physical existence. Without verification you have no control over your data. Without control, someone else could change it.

In London, in high-turnover areas like Hackney, Brixton, or Peckham, it's common to find listings for closed businesses sharing the same address as yours. Verifying your listing and flagging duplicates is the first step.

Step 2 — NAP: the holy trinity

Name, Address, Phone number (NAP) must be identical everywhere: on your website, your GBP listing, the Yellow Pages, Instagram. If your website says "12 Via Roma" and your GBP says "Via Roma, 12", Google treats them as two different entities. Be obsessive about it.

Step 3 — Primary and secondary categories

Choose the most specific primary category you can:

  • Gastropub rather than "Restaurant" (James in Hackney)
  • Joinery rather than "Artisan business" (Caserta supplier)
  • Beauty salon with secondary categories: Massage centre, Manicure, Facial treatments

Secondary categories broaden your semantic reach. Use at least 2–3.

Step 4 — Description: write for humans (the AI will read it too)

You've got 750 characters. Don't waste them on "we are a leading company". The structure that works: who you are + what you do + where you operate + why to choose you. With natural keywords woven in.

Example — Caserta: "Falegnameria artigianale a Caserta dal 1987. Realizziamo mobili su misura, cucine componibili e restauro arredi antichi. Serviamo privati e aziende in tutta la provincia di Caserta e Napoli."

Example — London: "Independent gastropub in the heart of Hackney since 2018. Real ales, seasonal Sunday roasts, private hire for up to 60 guests. Dog-friendly. Open daily."

Step 5 — Photos and video: the 30-day rule

Never let more than a month go by without uploading an original photo. Steer clear of stock images: Google recognises them and penalises them for lacking authenticity. Upload: exterior shots (to help people find you), interior, staff in action, finished products.

In Naples, a photo featuring a recognisable landmark visually geotags your business better than a thousand words. In London, the classic East End red brick does exactly the same job.

Five essential types of photo:

  • Exterior façade — for people coming to find you in person
  • Interior — to convey atmosphere
  • Team at work — to put a human face on the business
  • Products or completed work — to demonstrate quality
  • Logo — for brand recognition

Step 6 — Reviews: building your reputation systematically

Don't wait for them to roll in: ask for them. The ideal moment is right after you've solved a problem or delivered a product. You can use a QR code in the shop, or send the link via WhatsApp Business (a tremendously powerful tool for local contact, which we covered in this dedicated article).

How to respond:

  • Positive reviews: thank them briefly with a personal touch. Not a copy-paste job.
  • Negative reviews: professional, empathetic, and always offer to resolve things offline. Remember: you're writing for every future customer who'll read that response.

A note on tone: in Naples you can afford something warmer and more personal. In London, brevity and professionalism are the norm. Adapt your register to the market.

Step 7 — Google Posts: the mini-blog nobody's using

Google Posts are short announcements that appear directly on your listing. Three types: Update, Offer, Event. They last seven days, but they send Google a clear signal that you're active.

Practical example for Antonio in Portici: "This week: 20% off washing machine filters. Call us before Friday." — Time taken: 2 minutes. Signal received by the algorithm: "Active business."

Step 8 — FAQ: the section the AI loves

The Questions & Answers section is a goldmine for local AI Overviews. Don't wait for customers to write the questions: write them yourself and answer them. Google will use those answers to populate its automated responses.

Examples for a restaurant in Naples: "Accettate prenotazioni per gruppi?" / "C'è parcheggio nelle vicinanze?" / "Avete piatti senza glutine?"

Examples for a business in London: "Do you take card payments?" / "Are you dog-friendly?" / "Do you offer private hire?"

Tools for managing your GBP without losing the plot

You don't need to become a software engineer. For a single location in a classic local market, Google's free tools are more than sufficient. Paid tools start earning their keep when you're managing 2+ locations or looking after clients. Don't confuse the tool with the strategy.

Umberto Mazza, creative director at Insight ADV, analyses the Google Business Profile Insights dashboard on a laptop in a bright office

Tool

What it does

Price

Ideal for

GBP Insights (native)

Views, calls, directions, keywords. Data over 6 months.

Free

All SMEs — mandatory starting point

Google Search Console

Combines GBP data with your site's organic traffic.

Free

Anyone with a website who wants to join the dots

Google Analytics 4

Tracks conversions from users clicking through from your listing.

Free

Anyone who wants to measure the listing's ROI

BrightLocal

GBP audit, rank tracking, review management, white-label reports.

From $39/month per location

Agencies and multi-location businesses

Semrush Local

NAP distribution across 70+ directories, review responses, post scheduling.

From $30/month per location

Anyone already using Semrush for site SEO

Moz Local

NAP consistency, citation correction. Simplified interface.

From $14/month per location

Beginners who want clean data

⚠️ My advice

For the vast majority of SMEs in Campania — a beauty salon in Caserta, a joinery in Marcianise, a restaurant in the Quartieri Spagnoli — BrightLocal or Semrush are an unnecessary luxury. Ninety per cent of results come from Google's native dashboard, consistency, and thirty minutes a week. Invest in discipline first, tools later — if at all.

It's a different conversation entirely if you're an agency managing clients across different geographic markets. Insight ADV, based in London, manages local business profiles for clients in the UK (London, Manchester), Italy (Naples, Caserta), and other European markets — Poland, Finland, Germany, Bulgaria, Hungary. Monitoring the local ranking of each client, across different cities and different national versions of Google Maps, using only Google's native dashboard quickly becomes unmanageable: at that point, BrightLocal becomes almost essential for reporting and granular tracking.

The same applies to large companies with multiple physical locations in different cities: chains, franchises, professional networks. In those cases, centralised listing management isn't a nice-to-have — it's an operational necessity.

GBP in Naples/Caserta vs London: same rules, very different playing fields

Working across Campania and the UK has given me a perspective that very few Italian consultants have. The technology is identical: Google doesn't change the rules for Caserta or for Hackney. What changes is the playing field.

Photographic composition showing a Naples alley and a Hackney street side by side, symbolising the contrast between Italian and British local marketing

In Campania: the competition is digitally lazy

Open Google Maps in Caserta right now. You'll find dozens of excellent businesses with abandoned listings. A craftsman with twenty years of experience who replies to reviews, posts a photo a week, and has the right category set — in terms of local visibility — beats competitors with more staff and triple the turnover. The barrier to entry is incredibly low. The challenge here is cultural: convincing people that digital isn't an alternative to the real world, but the way customers find their way to your door.

In London: the battle is won on the details

In Hackney or Shoreditch, every small bistro has an owner who's a digital native or a social media expert on speed dial. GBP listings are generally well maintained. Simply existing isn't enough here: you need to be the best in your micro-neighbourhood. Response speed on reviews (often under two hours), photo quality, post frequency. The margins are tight, but they're still there in specific niches and local long-tail keywords.

The democratisation of local marketing

In both markets, the website is becoming secondary when it comes to local conversion. People make their decision on the listing. If your listing doesn't convince them, your website — however brilliant — will never see that click.

A small craftsman in Marcianise can beat a multinational if he looks after his local presence with more precision. That wasn't true in 2015. It very much is today.

✅ The 15-point checklist: check your listing right now

Pick up your phone, open your GBP listing, and tick off these items. If more than three are missing, you're losing customers every hour.

#

Action

Check

1

Verification

Is the listing verified and under your direct control?

2

Name

Is the name accurate and free of forced keywords?

3

NAP

Are the address and phone number identical to those on your website?

4

Hours

Are the opening hours correct for today (including bank holidays)?

5

Primary category

Is the category as specific as it can be?

6

Secondary categories

Have you added at least 2–3 secondary categories?

7

Description

Have you written a description of at least 500 characters?

8

Exterior photo

Is there a clear photo of the exterior?

9

Staff photos

Have you uploaded photos of the team or yourself at work?

10

No stock

Have you removed all stock or AI-generated photos?

11

Reviews

Have you responded to all reviews from the last 3 months?

12

Google Post

Have you published an update in the last 7 days?

13

FAQ

Have you added at least 5 questions and answers?

14

Messaging

Have you switched on the messaging feature for direct chat?

15

Insights

Have you checked your access data in the last week?

The salesperson who never sleeps

Back to Antonio and James.

Antonio, after our working sessions together, started putting half an hour a week into his listing. He took down the photo of the scrapped Scudo. Put up photos of his technicians smiling. Started asking long-standing customers for reviews, sending them a link via WhatsApp straight after each repair. Six weeks later, calls had increased significantly — without spending a single extra penny on advertising. He'd simply stopped handing his customers to Sergio.

Note: the results described are based on a real anonymised case, set within the typical dynamics of the local Campania market. Specific timescales and percentages vary from case to case.

James in Hackney realised that his website was for his ego, but the GBP was for his takings. He started posting real photos of the Sunday Roast every Sunday at 11:30am, half an hour before service. By February, the owner of The Rusty Anchor had come round to ask him: "But how are you always at the top of Maps?"

Your GBP listing is the most loyal employee you could ever have. It doesn't ask for a pay rise. It doesn't take holidays. It doesn't pull a sickie.

It works for you at three in the morning, when someone in Caserta has a plumbing emergency or a tourist in London is looking for somewhere to have a proper craft ale.

The only thing it asks is that you don't let it starve.

Feed it fresh information. Give it a bit of attention. And it'll send customers your way.

💬 Further reading

  • Want to understand how GBP fits into the new world of AI-generated responses? Read our in-depth piece on Local GEO for SMEs.
  • To complete the local communications picture, pair your GBP listing with WhatsApp Business as a CRM.

Frequently asked questions

What is Google Business Profile and why is it different from a website?

Google Business Profile (still referred to by many under its former name, Google My Business) is the listing that appears directly on Google Search and Google Maps when someone searches for your business or a similar service in their area. By 2026, it has become the real place where purchasing decisions are made: people do not search for your website to find out who you are, they look at the panel appearing on Google. If they do not find what they need there, the website — however beautiful — will never even be seen. The website is often for the ego; the GBP is for revenue.

How much time should be dedicated each week to managing a GBP listing?

For the vast majority of SMEs — a beauty salon in Caserta, a joinery workshop in Marcianise, a restaurant in the Spanish Quarter of Naples — 30 minutes per week, managed consistently, is enough. The practical actions are simple: one original photograph every 7–10 days, a short Google Post about the week’s activity, and replies to any new reviews. Consistency beats perfection: there is no need to write a novel, only to avoid disappearing for months. Google interprets silence as inactivity and lowers visibility accordingly.

What are the most common mistakes that cause businesses to lose customers on Google listings?

The five most common, in order of real-world damage. Incorrect or outdated opening hours: a potential customer sees “Closed” while you are actually inside the workshop with the shutters open — those customers go to a competitor with no chance of recovery. No photographs or photographs from 2019: in 2026 Google uses AI to analyse the visual content of images, so photographs are not decoration but data. Reviews left unanswered: failing to reply is like turning your back on a customer speaking to you in the shop. An overly generic primary category: registering as “Business activity” sends an extremely weak signal to the algorithm. And finally the zombie listing, with no updates for months: Google systematically lowers the visibility of inactive profiles.

How can you obtain more Google reviews without appearing pushy?

The ideal moment to ask for a review is immediately after solving a problem or delivering completed work — when customer satisfaction is at its peak. The most effective method is sending the direct review-page link through WhatsApp Business immediately after the service is completed, using a short and personal message. A QR code displayed in the shop or on the counter works well for walk-in customers. One important note: to appear in Google’s local AI Overviews, the profile must maintain a minimum rating of 4.5 out of 5 and include reviews with detailed written text. Every week without new reviews is a week in which your competitor moves closer.

How should you respond properly to a negative review?

A response to a negative review is not written for the person who posted it: it is written for every future customer who will read it. The sequence that works is straightforward: a professional and empathetic tone, no defensiveness, and a concrete proposal to resolve the issue offline through direct contact. Readers do not judge the mistake itself but how it is handled — a well-constructed response can transform a one-star review into a sign of professionalism. In Naples, the tone may be warmer and more personal; in London, brevity and professionalism are the norm. The worst mistake is ignoring the review entirely: Google interprets silence as confirmation of the issue.

Is a paid tool such as BrightLocal or Semrush necessary for managing a GBP listing?

For a single location operating in a standard local market, Google’s free tools — GBP Insights, Search Console and Google Analytics 4 — cover 90% of business needs. Paid tools become useful from the second location onwards or for agencies managing clients across multiple geographic markets. BrightLocal (from $39 per month per location) is almost essential for agencies monitoring local rankings for several clients across different cities and countries on Google Maps. Semrush Local (from $30 per month) makes sense for businesses already using the platform for website SEO. For the average SME in Campania: invest in discipline first, then eventually in tools.

Are the rules for optimising a GBP listing the same in Italy and the United Kingdom?

The technology is identical — Google does not change the rules for Caserta or Hackney — but the playing field is profoundly different. In Campania, digital competition is often lazy: a craftsman with twenty years of experience who replies to reviews and publishes one photograph a week can outperform competitors with triple the turnover but abandoned listings. The barrier to entry is low; the challenge is cultural. In London, in districts such as Hackney or Shoreditch, every business already has a polished profile: here it is not enough merely to exist, you must be the best in your own micro-neighbourhood. Review response times — often under two hours — make the difference where margins between similar businesses are razor-thin.

4.7 (24 voti)
Eyes Never Lie: The Complete Guide to Photographin...
Photographing Shadow: the Lesson of Ferdinando Sci...

Related Posts

 

Comments

No comments made yet. Be the first to submit a comment
Already Registered? Login Here
Wednesday, 18 November 2026

By accepting you will be accessing a service provided by a third-party external to https://insightadv.it/

Your weekly dose of Insight!

All our latest work. Every Monday in your inbox.

From Creative Writing to Photography, taking in Marketing and Design along the way. Every day we're busy prepping exclusive content to give you some fresh inspiration. Sign up so you don't miss a thing: every Monday at 09.30am you'll get the full weekly round-up. No spam. Just proper quality content, and you can unsubscribe whenever you like.

 

Satisfied customers

What they say about us

I also leave my testimony regarding the working relationship with Insight Agency, I have been a customer for years now and I am very very satisfied above all for the competence and availability as ...
2013-09-16
Read more
Luca Crocetti
CEO & Co-Founder / Lukkos
I had the opportunity to get to know Insight Agency when he started working with one of our clients, so I was able to appreciate not only their professional and creative approach, but above all the...
2013-09-16
Read more
Mario Gentile
CEO & Founder / Punto Ike
I have known Umberto for a few years and I can confirm that he is a professional in his field! Over time a good friendship has also been established which I am sure will last over time: it is prec...
2013-09-24
Read more
Pietro Sciannamblo
CEO & Founder / Esigaretta Italia

About

Insight Adv Ltd is a full-service advertising agency. We offer our customers Graphic and Web Design, Marketing and Strategic Communication services.

We create websites, e-commerce and fad platforms, commercials and promotional videos and applications for smartphones and tablets. We also offer digital & direct marketing, social media and content management services. 

Pills...

" You can’t just ask customers what they want and then try to give that to them. By the time you get it built, they’ll want something new. "
Steve Jobs

Follow us on