49 minutes reading time (9828 words)

Electoral marketing: how to build (and win) a campaign

 Umberto Mazza, creative director of Insight ADV, coordinates a strategic session for an electoral campaign in a Naples office

The night of 28 March 1994 wasn't just another date on the Italian electoral calendar: it was the precise moment the heartbeat of politics changed forever. I remember it well — that sense of suspended time you could feel in the newsrooms and the corridors of power. The day after, when the data stopped being projections and became reality, it was clear that one world had ended and another, alien and extraordinarily powerful, had just touched down. Achille Occhetto's "glorious war machine" was gone, crushed by a shockwave nobody had seen coming. In just sixty-eight days, Silvio Berlusconi had built a party from nothing, had occupied every centimetre of television airtime, and had won. Those of us who, like me, were working in journalism or studying the dynamics of communication in those years couldn't help but feel a strange sensation: a mixture of astonishment and disbelief and, if we're being intellectually honest, a deep technical respect for what had been achieved. It wasn't just politics — it was the most pure and ruthless form of marketing bursting into a temple that had always considered itself sacred and untouchable.

In my own direct experience — which began almost by accident as a candidate for the town council in my home town of Portici and later evolved into a role as communications lead on campaigns for national, regional and local elections — I've learned that politics has no mercy for those who ignore the rules of the game. I've seen at close quarters what separates a campaign that actually works, one capable of lighting a fire in voters' hearts, from one that simply "gives it a go", dragging itself wearily between ignored leaflets and half-empty rallies. The truth is that electoral marketing, once you strip away its ideological dressing, isn't all that different from commercial marketing. It has a product (the candidate or coalition), an audience (the electorate), an extremely tight time window (the campaign itself), an often limited budget, and objectives that are measured with brutal precision: votes. And yet it also has its own rules, an unwritten code that makes it a unique territory — fascinating in parts, terrifying in others.

This article comes from a desire to explore those rules — not as a dry academic manual, but as a reflection grounded in fieldwork. I've seen mistakes made out of arrogance, failures born from a lack of vision, and, let's be honest, I've made my own share of blunders that have served as valuable lessons. We'll look at what happens in Campania, in Naples and Caserta, but always with one eye fixed on London and Washington, because the dynamics of building consensus have gone global — even if the local territory remains the ultimate, irreplaceable judge. Fair warning from the off: this isn't a neutral handbook. It's a logbook, a map drawn by someone who has lived through the dust of provincial stages and the studio lights of television, trying to understand how you build that invisible yet steel-strong bond that leads a person to put a cross next to a name.

First things first: what kind of campaign are we actually talking about?

The first fundamental rule that every consultant or candidate must engrave in their mind is this: "the" electoral campaign in the singular doesn't exist. What exist are campaigns that are profoundly different from one another, each with its own pitfalls, its own language, and its own rhythms. Thinking you can apply the same communications framework to a European Parliament election and a race for the mayoralty of a town of fifty thousand people is the fastest route to disaster. The type of election and the candidate's profile fundamentally change the playing field, the distance between the message and those receiving it, and — above all — the tools you actually need to win.

Infografica Insight ADV: i quattro livelli di differenziazione del marketing elettorale — tipo di elezione e tipo di candidato

The level of the election: national, European, regional, local

When we talk about national or European elections, we're operating in the territory of pure vision. You're communicating a programme that needs to speak to millions of people, managing the complexity of coalitions that are often marriages of convenience, and trying to reach a vast, fragmented electorate. The message must be concise, almost iconic, capable of cutting across very different cultural contexts — from Milan to Naples — without losing its punch. In Italy, the fragmentation of the party system adds a layer of near-baroque complexity: every word must be carefully weighed so as not to antagonise an ally while, at the same time, differentiating yourself from them. The challenge here is memorability: how do you make an idea stick in the middle of a deafening background noise?

Moving down to regional level, the scale becomes intermediate. The issues become more concrete and closer to everyday life: healthcare, infrastructure, economic development. In Campania, for instance, the management of public health services has for decades been the dominant issue — the thermometer against which the success or failure of entire political classes has been measured. In the UK, elections for the Scottish or Welsh Parliaments have dynamics that diverge entirely from those of Westminster, centred on a national identity that overlaps with political identity.

But it's at local level that the territory becomes the main playing field and communication becomes hand-to-hand combat. The mayoral candidate is a recognisable figure, often physically reachable — someone you bump into at the café, someone you see walking the streets of your town. Here, personal relationships and social capital are worth as much as, and often more than, a billboard. It's the level at which I've had the most direct experience, and where I understood that politics is built on faces before it's built on symbols.

Who's at the centre of the campaign: coalition, party, or individual candidate

Another fundamental distinction is who we're actually communicating. If you're the face of a coalition or a candidate for prime minister, your primary job is to project unity — even when that unity is fragile or entirely absent behind the scenes. The party vote carries the weight of the whole system: the programme becomes a guiding document, but also a dangerous communications constraint. Berlusconi in 1994 taught everyone everything with "lower taxes for all" and "a million new jobs". Simple, concrete, measurable. Occhetto, on the other hand, had a detailed and arguably more robust programme in terms of content — but nobody remembered it, because it lacked the communicative impact that only genuine brevity can deliver.

When instead we're working for the individual candidate — the local councillor, regional representative or MP — the work is pure craftsmanship. Here you need to find one or two defining battles, an element of uniqueness that allows you to stand out from the other candidates on the same list without coming into conflict with the shared programme.

And this is where I see the most frequent mistake being made: confusing the role you're standing for with the powers that role doesn't actually have. A town councillor doesn't run the city. They don't set budgets, award contracts, or sign executive resolutions — they propose, scrutinise, and represent. They can put forward a motion on green spaces, push for a hearing with the relevant cabinet member, exercise oversight over the administration's conduct. A regional councillor can promote a legislative proposal, champion a specific cause, but they won't "solve youth unemployment" — that's a promise for a head of state, not a minority councillor. Being less glamorous but more precise about what you can realistically deliver always pays off in the long run, because it builds an expectation that can actually be met. And in political marketing, keeping your promise is worth more than any future campaign.

⚠️ Sidebar — The consistency problem

You can't champion environmental protection and then be spotted constantly behind the wheel of an SUV. You can't talk about legality and transparency while having backers whose finances don't add up. Voters may have selective memories, but they're rarely short ones — and today, with a smartphone in every pocket, someone always has proof of your inconsistency. Consistency between the candidate's message and their lifestyle is the first marketing test you need to pass.

Message, identity, slogan: the heart of the campaign

If the electoral system is the skeleton and the candidate is the body, the message is the beating heart of the campaign. Without a central idea, every creative effort — from graphics to videos — is merely an exercise in style that won't shift a single vote. People don't vote for a bullet-pointed list of good intentions; they vote for a vision, or more often, for a solution to a problem they feel burning on their own skin.

What do you want to say? Before you think about how to say it

James Carville, the architect of Bill Clinton's 1992 victory, hung a sign in the Little Rock campaign headquarters that became legendary: "It's the economy, stupid." It wasn't a slogan for posters — it was an internal reminder to stop the team losing the thread. The lesson is timeless: first decide what you're talking about, then find the way to say it.

In Italy, unfortunately, this strategic phase is often skipped entirely. I see candidates fretting over the font of their logo or the colour of their tie before they've even answered three fundamental questions: what is the main problem I want to solve for my voter? What genuinely differentiates me from my opponent on that issue? What am I prepared to defend at all costs, even if it costs me votes?

If you can't answer these questions, you're not doing electoral marketing — you're just taking up space. In Campania, I've seen campaigns change course simply by talking to people in the markets of Caserta or Portici, and realising that what the newspapers considered a priority was a thousand miles from the real concerns of ordinary families. The message must be a bridge between the candidate's vision and the voter's need. And that bridge is built only by listening, before you even begin to speak.

To explore how to build an authentic narrative starting from direct observation, read also ⟶  The narrative detective method

Building the narrative: the candidate as a character

One of the most valuable lessons I've drawn from working in the field is that the candidate must not be presented as a product, but as a character. Every story that works needs a coherent protagonist, deep motivations, and a conflict to resolve. David Axelrod, the mind behind the Obama phenomenon in 2008, used to say that voters need to "see themselves" in the story you tell. Obama wasn't just selling competence or a policy programme; he was selling the idea of a possible America, and his own personal story was living proof that the change was achievable. The message and the messenger were one and the same.

Tony Blair in 1997 with "New Labour" followed the same narrative mechanics. The story was simple: "we've changed." They were no longer the old Labour of trade unions and dusty nationalisations, but a modern, fresh movement ready to govern. On a local scale, here in Italy, I've seen mayors overturn desperate polling figures simply because their personal story was inextricably woven into the fabric of the territory. When voters sense that you're "one of us" who has decided to put their name on the line for a shared cause, the gap closes with remarkable speed.

Illustrazione concettuale Insight ADV: il candidato politico costruito come personaggio narrativo attraverso storia personale, conflitto e territorio

The slogan: not a phrase, but a point of view

A good slogan doesn't describe: it takes a clear position. In Campania we're inundated every election cycle with variations of "change is now" or "for our land" — phrases so empty they could be swapped between candidates of opposing factions without anyone noticing. The rules I've learned on the ground:

  • It must be short: fewer than seven words, or it won't be remembered.
  • It must be verifiable: it must suggest a concrete result, even if not an immediate one.
  • It must be unique: if your opponent could use it, bin it.
  • It must work out loud: easy to say at a rally or in a conversation at the café.
  • It must stand up to scrutiny: if you win, people will ask you how you delivered on it.

The slogan is the endpoint of a process of distilling identity. If it's good, it sums up your entire world in a single breath. If it's poor, it's just white noise that vanishes the moment you turn the corner.

See also ⟶  From a greenhouse in Caserta to London: how to build a brand that speaks two languages.

The electoral system changes the rules of the game: Italy vs the UK

A mistake I often see made by people coming from commercial marketing who approach politics is ignoring the technical impact of the electoral system on communications. The rules by which votes are converted into seats dictate the strategy: you don't communicate in the same way under a proportional system with preferential voting as you do under a single-round first-past-the-post system. Understanding electoral law isn't a job for lawyers — it's the first duty of a political communicator.

Italy: proportional, constituencies, and the hunt for preference votes

The current Italian system, the Rosatellum, is a complex hybrid incorporating both a majority and a proportional component. Whilst in national elections the party lists are closed and voters cannot choose individual names, everything changes completely in regional and local elections. Here, preferential voting exists — and this transforms the campaign into a dual challenge: you must promote your list or party whilst simultaneously running a personal campaign to collect your own individual preference votes.

In this context, your direct network of contacts becomes the most valuable resource you have, bar none. It's not just about persuading someone to vote for an idea — it's about persuading them to write your surname on the ballot paper. This requires a kind of micro-territorial marketing that has nothing to do with grand digital strategies. It's a matter of trust, phone calls, and small-group meetings. In Italy, and especially in the South, the personal trust relationship is still the primary engine of local consensus.

UK: First Past the Post and the logic of the constituency

In the UK, the logic is radically different. The First Past the Post system means that in any given constituency, the winner is whoever gets even just one more vote than anyone else, with no proportional compensation. This focuses the campaign almost entirely on the specific local area: a candidate in Westminster lives and dies by their constituency. Here, canvassers — the volunteers who go door to door — are not a romantic relic of the past but an organisational machine of devastating power.

The 2017 Labour campaign under Corbyn showed that a widespread network of volunteers can snatch seats historically considered safe for the opposition. In 2019, Boris Johnson used the slogan "Get Brexit Done" to simplify an infinitely complex issue and break through in traditionally Labour-voting areas of the north of England. The fundamental difference from Italy? In the UK, the national party sets the direction, but it's the local candidate who must "sell" that message door by door. In Italy, the local candidate is often a free agent who survives even when their national party is in freefall, clinging to their own personal networks of preference votes.

Political direct marketing: building the network before the campaign begins

We come now to what I consider the real secret of campaigns that win, particularly at local level: building a solid, wide-reaching network of relationships well before the campaign officially kicks off. In politics, exactly as in marketing for small businesses, the database is everything. But let's be clear — I'm not talking about a cold list of email addresses or phone numbers bought from goodness knows where. I'm talking about a capital of genuine relationships, people who trust you enough to put their own name on the line and act as your ambassadors.

For tools to manage direct relationships in 2026, read also ⟶  WhatsApp Business: the CRM you've already got in your pocket

Your network is your social capital

I've seen candidates for the town council in cities like Caserta or Aversa start with an unassailable advantage simply because they'd spent the previous two years building a network of trust. If you have two hundred people ready to personally ring friends and colleagues to ask for a vote on your behalf, you are infinitely stronger than someone with ten thousand Instagram followers but nobody willing to put their neck out in the real world. A vote is an act of delegating trust, and trust travels best through direct channels.

A candidate who wakes up two months before polling day and tries to "get their name out there" has already lost against someone who has been seen as a point of reference for months or years. Your database must be nurtured constantly — with useful information, with your presence at local events, with the ability to listen before you ask anything in return.

Ambassadors: who they are and how to build the network

The most effective ambassadors aren't your "fans" — they're people who themselves hold social capital in the community and choose to associate it with your name. They are the multipliers of your message. To find them, you need to look at specific categories:

  • Leaders of sports and cultural associations: people who have daily contact with hundreds of families.
  • Respected professionals: doctors, solicitors, architects who carry a natural authority in their field.
  • Local business owners and trade representatives: people who live the economic difficulties of the area and can speak to their peers.
  • Community activists: those figures — sometimes informal — who know everyone and know everything that happens on a given street or square.
  • Structured organisations: associations, social cooperatives, professional bodies, educational institutions. Where there's a chair, there's a multiplier.

Building this network can't be done once the campaign is already under way. If you ask a favour from someone you haven't seen in ten years just because you've put yourself forward as a candidate, you'll come across as an opportunist. The network is built when you don't need it, by demonstrating that you're a genuine resource for the community.

One final point, often overlooked: these relationships must be maintained and nurtured after the campaign, regardless of the outcome. Those who put their name on the line for you remember whether they were thanked or forgotten. And that's the difference between someone who builds a political career and someone who burns through their entire capital in a single election.

Umberto Mazza, political communications consultant at Insight ADV, in an informal meeting with representatives of local civic associations in Campania

Timing: the campaign nobody sees

Time is the most democratic and at the same time the most tyrannical resource in any electoral campaign. A winning campaign is like an iceberg: what voters see in the final thirty days is just the tip. The work that actually matters is the submerged part — months or years of presence, relationships, and positioning.

The ideal scenario: one or two years out

A solid candidacy doesn't begin with the announcement of rallies. It begins when you've already started staking out the issues on which you want to build your political identity, when your public presence is established enough not to appear improvised. If you want to be known as "the one who champions the environment", you need to have been fighting environmental battles long before the campaign starts. You should already have thought about your team: who will manage your communications, who will hold together the territorial network, who will handle logistics. In the UK, serious candidates begin working their constituencies up to three years in advance. In Italy we tend to compress everything to the last minute, but the logic doesn't change: whoever starts earlier gets further.

The emergency scenario: how to run a campaign in two months

What if there's no time? What if the candidacy comes out of nowhere, or you accept an "impossible" challenge? It's happened to me directly, and the good news is that it can be done. The bad news is that it requires iron discipline and brutally clear choices about where to concentrate your energy.

✅ Checklist: how to build an effective campaign in two months

1. Define your message within 48 hours. You haven't got time for focus groups. Decide who you are and what you're saying, then don't change it. Extreme consistency will compensate for the lack of time. A mediocre message delivered consistently beats a brilliant one that shifts every week.

2. Put everything into your ambassadors. Don't try to speak to everyone. Identify the 10–15 people who can carry your message to different groups. Ten real people willing to put their name on the line for you will beat a thousand digital followers who never leave the house.

3. Choose a defined physical territory. You can't be everywhere. Pick the squares or neighbourhoods where your presence genuinely makes a difference and hold them consistently. Better to be the go-to person in three areas than a ghost across the whole city.

4. Use digital as an amplifier, not a substitute. Only post on social media what you're actually doing on the ground. Don't fabricate a digital life that doesn't exist. Digital works when it reflects a real presence — not when it replaces one.

5. Organise at least three meaningful public events. Not formal rallies: meetings, round tables, appearances at markets, local fairs, sports clubs. Go where people already are. Three well-attended and well-documented events are worth twenty empty ones.

Territorial analysis: knowing where you're strong before you know where you want to go

There's a phase of campaign work that almost always happens late at night, over spreadsheets or badly bound printed maps, pencil in hand and a generous dose of coffee: territorial analysis. It's the least glamorous part of the whole campaign — the sort of thing that never makes the papers, and that no candidate enjoys doing because it forces you to look reality square in the face with no filter. And it's probably the most important part.

Reading the territory: data, polling districts, streets

Where possible, you work from the historical record of electoral results. At national or regional level, you analyse by council areas and constituencies. But it's when you drill down to local level that this work becomes a kind of art form: district by district, sometimes street by street, you try to understand where your party, your movement or your candidacy has genuine roots and where it's standing on sand.

The data you're looking for is simple but revealing: the percentage of votes received in the previous round in each polling district, the turnout, the change compared to the election before that. From these numbers, three types of territory emerge — each requiring a completely different strategy.

Strong areas are those where your presence is well established, where your ambassadors are deeply rooted, where your name or symbol generates spontaneous support. Here the work is about holding and defending: you don't need to convince anyone, you need to not let them down, not to take them for granted, not to assume they'll always be there — because the safe vote is the easiest vote to lose through inattention.

Contested areas are those where the historical result is uncertain, where the opponent isn't clearly dominant, and where a targeted investment of energy can tip the balance. This is where the real game is played — it's in these territories that a close election is won or lost.

Opposition strongholds are those where your foothold is weak and your competitor's is solid. Here the question isn't "how do I win?" but "how much resource does it make sense to invest knowing the return will be limited?" Sometimes the right answer is: don't invest there at all, and redirect your energy where it can genuinely make a difference.

This analysis isn't just useful for planning resources — it's essential for not wasting them. A campaign that spreads its energy, leaflets, and presence uniformly across the whole territory as though it were homogeneous is a campaign that hasn't understood where elections are actually won.

My mistake: when the stronghold becomes the most vulnerable point

There's an episode I've carried with me for years — one of those you don't tell willingly, but that's worth more than any textbook.

The first time I stood for the town council in Portici, my campaign had been built around a specific neighbourhood. I knew it well — I'd built relationships there over time, I was present, I was a recognisable face. In that neighbourhood, I was someone people trusted. The result was that it delivered the largest share of my preference votes, and that area was the engine of my election. I was the highest-polling candidate.

When I stood again, I reasoned — wrongly — with the logic of commercial expansion: I've already consolidated there, now I need to open new markets. I invested time, energy, and resources in strengthening my position in other parts of the town, convinced that my stronghold would defend itself. I didn't need to protect what I already had, I thought. I needed to win what I hadn't yet.

It was a mistake I paid for dearly.

While I was busy trying to build support elsewhere, my neighbourhood — the place where I'd been born politically — was targeted by my opponents. They knew exactly where my strength lay, every bit as well as I did, and they focused on it with surgical precision. The relationships I hadn't tended carefully enough began to fray. The sense of "one of us" I'd built over years faded the moment I stopped being physically present. When the results came in, my neighbourhood had given me fewer votes than it ever had before, and the new areas hadn't made up the shortfall.

The lesson is brutally simple: an abandoned stronghold becomes your most vulnerable point. Precisely because it's where your support is highest, it's also where opponents will concentrate their attacks when you're not there to defend it. A stronghold doesn't hold itself — it needs to be protected with the same intensity with which it was won, otherwise it crumbles faster than any contested area.

The paradox is this: expansion is right, it's necessary, it's the logic of any kind of growth. But you don't expand by abandoning your foundations. You expand by first ensuring the foundations are solid, covered, and protected. Consolidate first, then conquer. Not the other way round.

How to distribute resources: a practical compass

On the basis of this experience — and of many other campaigns observed and managed in the years that followed — I've settled on an operational rule of thumb that I recommend to anyone planning a local campaign:

Allocate 50% of your energy to your strong areas. Not to win them — you've already won them — but to avoid losing them. Consistent presence, direct contact with your ambassadors, tending to relationships: all of this must continue as though you were still building from scratch. The consolidated vote is the most expensive to recover once it's gone.

Allocate 35% to contested areas. This is where you invest to win. This is where it makes sense to concentrate events, physical presence, campaign materials, and digital resources. It's the territory where the return on investment is highest.

Allocate 15% to opposition strongholds. Not to win them — that almost certainly won't happen — but to be present, to avoid signalling total absence, to pick up a few votes that in a preferential system can make the difference. And above all: to learn. Direct engagement with the territories where you're weakest tells you things about your opponent and about yourself that no opinion poll ever will.

These figures aren't absolute — they depend on context, on the type of election, on the degree of competitiveness. But as a rule of thumb, they work. And above all, they force you to do something that many candidates put off until the last possible moment: decide. Decide where you're going, where you're not going, and why.

Visual diagram by Insight ADV: how to distribute campaign resources between strong, contested, and opposition areas

Studying your opponents: their numbers tell you more than their words

Analysing historical electoral data isn't just about understanding yourself — it's about understanding them. And "them" doesn't only mean the candidates from the other side.

When you have the district-by-district results of previous elections in front of you, you can do something worth its weight in gold: overlay your map onto your opponents'. Where was he strong when you were weak? Where has his percentage dropped since the previous round — is there a pool of votes that shifted, or simply stayed home? In which neighbourhood was his result above his party's average, suggesting a personal rooting — and therefore a resistance — that goes deeper than simple party allegiance?

These overlaps tell you where it makes sense to challenge him directly and where it's smarter to work on consolidating your own position without wasting energy on a fight you can't win. The difference between a direct assault on an opponent's territory and a gradual erosion strategy is entirely in the reading of the numbers: if his percentage in a given polling district has been stable across three elections, you're most likely fighting against something structural — relationships, family ties, personal history — that no short-term campaign will shift. If it's declining, though, there's an opening.

Studying opponents through data also means understanding their strategy. A candidate who grows strongly on the outskirts whilst conceding ground in the centre is probably targeting a specific electorate. A party that loses votes in polling districts with high youth turnout is suffering on a specific issue. The numbers never lie the way statements do.

The rival sleeping in your bed: candidates on your own list

Here we enter territory that nobody talks about willingly, but that anyone who has campaigned for a town council seat knows perfectly well: sometimes your most dangerous opponent isn't the candidate from the other side — it's the candidate running alongside you.

In elections with preferential voting, every candidate on the same list is technically an ally — they bring votes to the list — but also a direct competitor for personal preferences. And preferences decide who gets in and who stays out. There's no diplomatic way to put it: if there are thirty of you on the list and only six seats available, fourteen of you won't get in, regardless of how well the list performs overall.

Territorial analysis in this context becomes even more granular. You need to know not just where you're strong, but where they're strong. If your running mate has solid roots in the north of the borough and you have yours in the south, the coexistence is manageable: you're drawing from different pools and not cannibalising each other. But if you both have your roots in the same neighbourhood, the same club, the same network of associations, then you're competing for the same votes — and one of you has a problem.

I've seen internal campaigns within a single list become more fierce than the campaigns against the actual opponents. Shared ambassadors who split, crossed promises, unwritten agreements that collapse on the eve of polling day. These are dynamics that grind everyone down and weaken the whole effort — and they generally play straight into the hands of the other coalition.

The healthiest way to manage them — and the rarest, because it requires an uncommon degree of political maturity — is explicit, agreed territorial division. You sit round a table before the campaign starts, look at the historical data together, and divide the field: you cover these polling districts, I'll cover those, and on the shared list we build a unified message. It's not a surrender — it's a strategy. The vote for the list grows when candidates strengthen each other rather than undermining one another.

In practice, this agreement usually holds until the end of the first week of campaigning. Then everyone follows their own survival instinct. But having at least tried, having the data clearly in hand from the start, allows you to spot immediately when someone is straying into your territory — and to respond precisely rather than just on gut feeling.

Territorial analysis, in short, isn't just a map of where you are. It's a map of where everyone else is. And in politics, knowing where your neighbour stands — ally or opponent — is worth as much as knowing where you stand yourself.

The internal competition for list votes: the "useful vote" that sinks you

"Vote for me, he hasn't got a chance": how it starts and how it spreads.

There's a tactic that circulates in hushed tones in every preferential campaign — difficult to intercept and even harder to confront head-on: the internal useful vote. It works like this. A running mate — or someone working for them — begins seeding a message through shared networks, WhatsApp groups, conversations at the café: "Vote for so-and-so, because the other one hasn't got a chance. It'd be a wasted vote."

It's an insidious tactic because it takes the form of friendly advice. It's not an attack, it's not a criticism, it says nothing bad about you. It simply says you're going to lose. And the message carries an apparent logic that makes it believable: anyone who wants their vote to actually count, who doesn't want to "waste" it, is naturally inclined to think in exactly these terms. It's the same mechanism as tactical voting in a general election, applied at the microscopic scale of council preference votes.

The added difficulty is that this message doesn't travel through official channels where you can respond to it. It's not a poster you can tear down, not a statement you can rebut at a press conference. It's a whisper spreading through personal networks, in places where you have no direct access. By the time you hear about it, the damage is often already done.

How do you defend yourself without amplifying the message?

A direct response is almost always counterproductive. If you call out the tactic publicly, you're amplifying the very message you want to bury: you're confirming, in the eyes of everyone who hadn't yet heard about it, that someone is saying you can't win. It's the same negation trap we'll come to shortly — don't repeat the words of the attack in your response.

The effective response is indirect and preventive. It works on two fronts simultaneously.

The first is concrete, visible proof of vitality. An intense physical presence in the areas that matter, events with genuine attendance, photographs of crowds, figures doing the rounds — how many people you've met, how many houses you've visited, how many appointments are in your diary. Not to answer the accusation, but to create a parallel narrative of a candidate in the race that speaks for itself. People don't back someone who looks like they're losing — they back someone who looks like they're moving. Your job is to look like you're moving — better still, to actually be moving — so visibly that it becomes difficult to argue otherwise.

The second is covering the local networks. The internal useful vote spreads through the same networks where consensus is built: neighbourhood chats, groups of mutual friends, clubs. Your ambassadors in those spaces are your only real answer. Not to rebut — but to provide direct testimony: "I believe in them, I know them personally, I'm backing them, and I'm telling you they're going to do it." One credible voice inside a network is worth ten press releases outside it.

There's also the matter of building credibility preventively, long before the internal useful vote tactic can gain any traction. If in the preceding weeks you've built a visible presence, if your level of support is perceived as solid, if the message circulating about you is that of a well-rooted and competitive candidate, then the ground on which that tactic tries to take hold is far less fertile. The internal useful vote works best against candidates who never fully convinced even their own supporters. Against someone who has built a solid base, it gets a lot less purchase.

The final lesson, though, is as honest as it is sobering: in a list with preferential voting, there's no such thing as genuine solidarity between candidates. There's temporary mutual interest. There's the convenience of running together for as long as it's convenient. But when polling day approaches and seats are limited, everyone looks after their own. Knowing this in advance doesn't make you cynical — it makes you prepared.

Case study: 1994 and the lesson everyone knew but nobody had learned

It was February 1994. Occhetto's "glorious war machine" was so certain of victory that the leaders of the left were already discussing the composition of the future government in the newspapers. An atmosphere of self-congratulation that, in marketing terms, we'd call an announced strategic disaster.

While they were debating grand schemes, something was being assembled in the Publitalia offices in Milan that Italian politics had never seen before. Berlusconi wasn't building a party in the traditional sense — he was creating a political franchise. He used his network of sales reps — people trained to persuade customers, to hit targets, to close deals — to sell a candidate. The Forza Italia "candidate kit" was standardised: coordinated graphics, pre-approved messages, sales techniques applied to politics. From 26 January, the date of his historic video address, to the elections of 27–28 March 1994: sixty-eight days.

Timeline grafica: i 68 giorni della campagna di Forza Italia nel 1994, dal videomessaggio del 26 gennaio alle elezioni del 27-28 marzo

What won that campaign

The absolute simplicity of the message. "Lower taxes for everyone." "A million new jobs." Any voter knew what they were signing up for. Occhetto had a detailed and arguably more robust programme in terms of substance — but who could remember it?

The medium as the message. Berlusconi owned three national television networks, and impartiality rules didn't yet exist. But beyond the structural advantage, he grasped before anyone else that television wasn't an information channel — it was a performance arena. In the famous head-to-head with Occhetto on Canale 5, moderated by Enrico Mentana, he won on image: Berlusconi beaming with his Forza Italia lapel badge, his opponent in a brown suit that disappeared into the studio shadows. The debate was watched by 9.5 million viewers with a share of 61.3%. A subsequent SWG poll found that 41% of Italians judged Berlusconi the winner, against 23.7% who chose Occhetto. It wasn't even close.

The anti-establishment positioning. In a country devastated by the Tangentopoli corruption scandal, where almost all the established parties were implicated, Berlusconi was the only viable candidate for "the new". Despite being a businessman who had done deals with the old political class, he managed to position himself as the man of action against the professional talkers.

What the "glorious war machine" got wrong

Certainty of victory created strategic complacency: when you're convinced you're going to win, you stop working to win. The response to the newcomer was to attack the person — the conflict of interest, the television channels as instruments of manipulation — rather than advancing a stronger alternative offer. Personal attacks work if you've already persuaded the voter that you're the better option; if you're still trying to win them over, the attack locks you into a defensive frame that's very hard to escape.

The language was still that of the First Republic: the rallies, the press releases, the political broadcasts. Berlusconi, meanwhile, spoke like a salesman, not a politician. And that year, in that Italy, was exactly what people wanted to hear. Thirty years on, that campaign remains the sacred text of Italian electoral marketing because it proved that politics is won with the same tools used to sell a product — provided that product is capable of capturing the desire of an entire country.

What the great strategists say: three universal lessons

There's no need to reinvent the wheel every time. The history of political communications has given us pearls of wisdom that remain valid regardless of the technology we use. I've selected three lessons from the world's greatest strategists that I've seen work consistently in the local realities of Campania.

🎯 The 3 lessons from the great strategists

1. James Carville (Clinton 1992) — "Define the race"

Whoever manages to set the terms of the debate has already won half the battle. If you allow your opponent to decide what's being talked about — say, your supposed past mistakes rather than your future programme — you're on the back foot. Clinton kept winning because every time he was attacked, he steered the conversation back to the economy. In Campania, if you can shift the discussion onto the concrete issues that matter to people, you disarm anyone who lives purely on ideological point-scoring.

2. David Axelrod (Obama 2008) — "Voters need to see themselves"

Politics is an act of emotional identification. Your programme may be flawless, but if people don't feel that your story has points of contact with their own, you'll always be an outsider. At local level, this means the candidate must be culturally and humanly of the territory. Being born somewhere isn't enough — you need to speak its language, know its silences and its hopes.

3. Alastair Campbell (Blair/New Labour) — "Discipline, discipline, discipline"

Blair's press secretary and strategist was obsessed with message control: no candidate spoke outside the agreed lines, no minister gave an unauthorised interview. In an election campaign, improvisation is the enemy. Every off-message remark from a supporter or a fellow candidate becomes a negative headline that costs you time and energy. Discipline isn't the absence of freedom — it's the ability to stay focused on the final objective without getting distracted by the background noise.

Own goals and failed strategies: when marketing sinks you

Studying successes is useful, but studying failures is often more instructive. In political marketing, mistakes don't just cost money — they cost reputation and votes that won't come back.

The promise you can't keep

I remember a candidate standing in the regional elections who insisted on including in his campaign materials the promise to deliver a specific public works project in a key town. It was a rash promise, dependent on uncertain national funding. I suggested softening it to "a commitment to pursue the funding", but he wasn't having any of it. The project was never built, for reasons beyond anyone's control. Five years later, at the next election, his opponents didn't even have to try: they simply reprinted his old leaflet and circulated it. The loss of credibility was total and permanent.

The disconnect between message and medium

It's the kind of mistake that smacks of amateurism, yet it still happens. The candidate who champions environmental sustainability and then plasters the city with enormous non-recyclable plastic posters. Or the "man of the people" who turns up to rallies in deprived areas in an official car with a driver. These contradictions get noticed immediately. Today's voter is a critical observer — if they sense that your marketing is nothing more than a mask with nothing behind it, they'll punish you with contempt, which is worse than simply not voting for you.

The digital campaign that replaces the real one

I followed closely a local council campaign in a town in the Naples hinterland where the candidate had an immaculate profile, professional photographs, reels put together by an agency, and absolutely zero presence in the places that counted: the Saturday morning market, the sports club, the local churches. His opponent — with an Instagram profile that looked like it was run by his twelve-year-old nephew — won by thirty votes. Likes don't vote; people do.

For a guide to local digital presence that actually works ⟶  Local GEO — how Campanian and British SMEs dominate AI responses in their area

Managing the unexpected: crises, attacks, and the thin line between timing and opportunism

There's one aspect of electoral marketing that rarely gets covered in textbooks, perhaps because it's hard to systematise: the ability to respond to what you didn't see coming. And in an election campaign, the unexpected isn't the exception — it's the rule.

When reality barges into the campaign

A building collapses in a working-class neighbourhood. A sinkhole opens on the high street at three in the morning. A femicide that shakes the entire city. An industrial accident at a local factory. The campaign you'd been running according to plan comes to a dead stop, and in that moment you face a choice with enormous consequences: respond, or stay silent?

The wrong response is to react as a candidate. The right response is to react as a human being.

The distinction seems subtle, but it's everything. If the day after a building collapse you put out a press release beginning "As a candidate for mayor, I consider it unacceptable that...", you're using someone's grief to run your campaign. Voters can feel it. They always can — even the less attentive ones. There's a threshold of decency that marketing cannot cross without paying a price.

If instead you're physically present on the ground, talking to the affected families, listening without cameras and without press releases, and only later — once the acute moment has passed — you raise the political issue with respectful restraint, then you're doing something different: you're showing that you're cut from the same cloth as the people you want to represent.

A candidate present in the community during a moment of collective difficulty: the difference between being a person and running a campaign

The principle I've held to in years of fieldwork is this: first the human being, then the candidate. And sometimes the candidate doesn't need to appear at all. A quiet, respectful presence during a moment of collective grief is worth more than ten rallies. A dignified silence is worth more than a statement of platitudes.

Timing matters enormously, though. When something serious strikes the community, the candidate's complete silence reads as distance, coldness, indifference. There's a window — usually the first few hours — in which a human word, not a political one, not an exploitative one, is not just permissible but necessary. Waiting too long is almost worse than saying nothing: you've missed the moment, and whatever you say afterwards will always carry the whiff of calculation. The subject of timing in communications is explored in depth in the article on real-time marketing ⟶ The art of the moment: a strategic guide to real-time marketing — where the line between an authentic response and calculated opportunism is as thin as a thread."

Responding to attacks: don't validate the enemy's frame

The other ever-present curveball in any campaign is attacks from opponents. And here a complex psychological game is played, with a golden rule I've seen violated dozens of times: never repeat the words of the attack in your response.

If your opponent attacks you by shouting "Candidate X is unreliable", the wrong response is "I am not unreliable." You're embedding the word "unreliable" next to your name in the voter's mind. When the brain hears a negation, it first constructs the image, then attaches the "not" to it. Saying "I'm not corrupt" is a communications disaster. Far better to shift the ground: "The people of this community have learnt to judge me by my actions, not by what others say."

The second common mistake in handling attacks is responding either too quickly or too slowly. Too quickly means amplifying the attack before it has gained any traction: if you respond immediately to a rumour that was only circulating in a small circle, you're bringing it to everyone's attention. Too slowly means allowing the narrative to solidify without any counter-weight. The right window depends on context, but in my experience the 24-hour rule still holds: beyond that point, silence starts to look like confirmation.

Then there's the question of responding to your own mistakes. It happens in every campaign: a poorly calibrated statement, a photograph in the wrong place, an ill-judged remark from one of your supporters. The temptation is to minimise, deny, deflect. It's almost always the wrong move. Acknowledge quickly, explain without over-justifying, and return immediately to your main message: that's the sequence that, in my experience, has always worked best. Voters don't expect perfection — they expect honesty.

The scout, the photograph, and the price of authenticity

There's an episode I tell often when working with candidates, because it captures in a few seconds everything you need to know about authentic communication — and its cost.

We were mid-campaign for a local council election. Our mayoral candidate was a competent, well-prepared person with a clear vision for the city. But he was perceived as cold, rational, distant — the sort who knows everything but can't quite make you feel he genuinely cares. It was his communications Achilles heel, and we all knew it.

One morning, in a café in the town centre, something happened that nobody had planned. A young boy — a scout, in full uniform — came up to the candidate and asked him something. He crouched down. Not just a few centimetres: he came all the way down, to nearly knee level, with his full attention focused on that child. There was a paternal tenderness in that gesture — the same you'd see in any father with his own child — that no professional in the world could have scripted. I was standing there with a camera in my hand. I took the shot.

That photograph did the work of weeks of campaigning. Not because it was staged — it was the exact opposite. It worked precisely because it was real, spontaneous, unmistakeable. It showed a dimension of the candidate that the public had never seen, and that was completely genuine: his deep humanity. The cold rationalist who spoke at conferences was the same man who got down on his knees in front of a child to listen more carefully.

But for exactly that reason, it became a target. His opponents — and some of the press — piled on: it was a propaganda shot, the child had been "used", the scene had been staged. The accusations were groundless, but they had their own logic: when a piece of content lands that hard, those who are damaged by it try to dismantle it. And dismantling authenticity is easier than it sounds, because all you need to do is plant a seed of doubt.

The response that worked wasn't technical — it wasn't "here's proof the photo wasn't staged." It was human: "Anyone who has children knows what they're looking at in that photograph." Full stop. No documents, no detailed rebuttal. A single sentence that returned the final judgement to where it belonged: the eyes of those looking.

The lesson I took from that episode is twofold. First: authentic content is simultaneously the most powerful and the most vulnerable kind. Precisely because it reaches straight to people's hearts, it automatically becomes the primary target of attacks. You need to be ready to defend it, and the defence must be equally human. Second: there is no impactful communication without the risk of attack. If you're not receiving attacks, you're probably not saying anything worth saying. Attacks, paradoxically, confirm that you've found something true.

A mayoral candidate crouches down to listen to a young scout during the election campaign: the moment of authenticity that changed the public's perception of the candidate

Digital in electoral marketing: a tool, not an identity

In 2026 you can't run a campaign without digital, but you can't run a campaign on digital alone. It must be integrated into a broader strategy, with clear objectives for each channel.

WhatsApp has become the most powerful direct marketing tool available to a local candidate. A personal message from a friend you trust is worth more than a thousand sponsored posts. This is where the real game of modern word-of-mouth is played. Read ⟶  WhatsApp Business in 2026.

Facebook and Instagram remain essential for image-building and for reaching the age groups who vote most consistently (forty and above). They're excellent for sharing behind-the-scenes content and putting a human face on the candidate.

The candidate's website is often dismissed as a relic, but it's the only space you actually own. It should be the landing point for anyone seeking detailed information about the programme. A slow or poorly structured site is the first sign of an unserious operation. Read ⟶  The website that doesn't convert.

TikTok is useful for brand awareness and for reaching first-time voters, but be careful not to come across as ridiculous trying to imitate a language that isn't yours. Authenticity always beats a forced performance.

The principle that applies across every channel is the same one: digital amplifies what already exists in the real world — it doesn't create it from nothing. A strong territorial presence backed by solid digital coverage is unbeatable. A purely digital presence is a sandcastle.

UK vs Italy: a final reflection

Having lived and worked between Naples, Caserta and London, I can't help but notice how deeply cultural differences shape political marketing.

In Italy, voting is still very much tied to personal relationships and to belonging to local networks. The candidate needs to be capable of navigating a fragmented system where, often, the toughest battle is the one inside their own coalition. Party fragmentation creates campaigns within the campaign: the candidate has to contend with the internal dynamics of the list, not just with external opponents.

In the UK, by contrast, discipline is far more rigid. The first-past-the-post system demands extreme geographical focus, but the national party machine is omnipresent and consistent. The tradition of door knocking is something Italy should rediscover: there's nothing more powerful than standing on a voter's doorstep and listening to their concerns before you ever put your own case. In Italy we prefer the loud rally; in the UK they prefer the quiet conversation on the front step. Both, however, require one fundamental thing: the courage to put your face on the line.

Read also ⟶ From a greenhouse in Caserta to London: how to build a brand that speaks two languages

Visual comparison between voting cultures in Italy and the United Kingdom: the Neapolitan rally versus British door knocking

Conclusion

There's no such thing as the perfect electoral campaign, just as there's no such thing as the perfect candidate. What does exist are campaigns that are well prepared — capable of anticipating the opponent's moves and speaking to people's hearts and minds with equal force.

The lesson of 1994, beyond any political judgement, taught us that ignoring the tools of marketing is a luxury that anyone seeking public support can no longer afford. Berlusconi had understood something that the Italian left couldn't bring itself to accept: modern politics is marketing. Not in the pejorative sense, but in the most precise one: understand your audience, find the right message, build the right channels, reach where your opponent doesn't.

In my experience, from that first adventure in Portici to the most recent consultancy work, I've come to understand that in the end everything comes down to a single word: authenticity. You can have the best graphic designer in the world, the highest-paid social media manager and the catchiest slogan, but if voters sense that you're playing a part that isn't really yours, the whole effort will be wasted. The campaigns that work are those that manage to translate a human truth into a political offer.

Marketing isn't there to "dress up" reality — it's there to make it visible through all the noise. It's there to ensure that a valid idea doesn't go to waste simply because it was communicated badly. And if you're a candidate reading these lines whilst preparing your next battle, remember: people aren't looking for a superhero. They're looking for someone who speaks their language and is ready to do what they say. Everything else is just technique.

Are you working on an election campaign, or thinking about standing? Drop me a line directly. I've seen strategies that have worked miracles and others that have sunk brilliant careers over small misjudgements. Having that conversation beforehand is always the smartest move.

Read also ⟶ Electoral graphics: how design wins or loses local council elections.

Don't miss tomorrow's article on electoral photography. A complete guide dedicated to how to photograph a candidate. How to prepare them without making them look like a waxwork. How to choose locations that tell the story of the territory. How to build the campaign reportage that gives a sense of a real, rooted person. Because, never forget: in an election campaign, people don't vote for a symbol or a programme. They vote for a face they feel they can trust.

Frequently asked questions

What is electoral marketing and how does it differ from commercial marketing?

Electoral marketing applies the logic of commercial marketing to the pursuit of political consensus: it has a product (the candidate or coalition), an audience (the electorate), a rigid timeframe (the campaign), and a brutally measurable objective — votes. The fundamental difference lies in the unwritten code governing the sector: a promise made during the campaign becomes a verifiable public commitment, and keeping it matters more than any future marketing action. Those who break that promise do not pay the price at the next election — they pay for it at the one after that as well.

What are the strategic differences between campaigns for national, regional, and local elections?

In national and European elections, the message must be iconic and capable of crossing very different cultural contexts, from Milan to Naples, without losing strength. In regional elections, the issues become more concrete — healthcare, infrastructure, economic development — and the territory takes on increasing importance. In local council elections, the campaign becomes hand-to-hand combat: the candidate is recognisable, physically reachable, and personal relationships matter as much as posters, often more. Applying the same communication model to different electoral levels is the quickest route to disaster.

How far in advance should an election campaign begin to take shape?

The ideal scenario is to begin one or two years beforehand. Anyone wishing to become "the person who cares about the environment" should already have fought environmental battles before the campaign even begins. In the United Kingdom, serious candidates often start working on their constituencies up to three years in advance. If time is lacking — a last-minute candidacy, an apparently impossible challenge — it is still possible to build an effective campaign in two months, but it requires brutally clear choices: define the message within 48 hours, focus entirely on ambassadors, and dominate a limited physical territory rather than trying to be everywhere.

How important is digital communication compared with physical presence within the local area?

Digital communication amplifies what already exists in the real world — it does not create it from nothing. A strong local presence supported by solid digital activity is almost unbeatable; a purely digital presence is a castle built on sand. One directly observed case proves it: a candidate with a perfectly curated profile, professional photographs, and agency-produced reels lost against an opponent with a terribly managed Instagram account, because the latter was present at the Saturday morning market, sports clubs, and parish events. Likes do not vote. People do.

How do you respond to an attack from opponents without amplifying it?

The golden rule is never to repeat the words of the attack in your response. Saying "I am not unreliable" plants the word "unreliable" next to your name in the voter’s mind — the brain creates the image first and only afterwards processes the "not". It is far better to shift the ground entirely: "The people of this area judge me by my actions, not by the words of others." In terms of timing, the 24-hour rule still applies: beyond that point, silence begins to resemble confirmation. Responding too quickly, however, risks amplifying an attack that was previously circulating only within a limited circle.

What are strongholds, battleground areas, and opposition zones, and how should resources be distributed between them?

Strongholds are areas where support is already consolidated: they require constant presence and defence, they do not protect themselves. Battleground areas are those where the historical result is uncertain and where the real contest takes place — this is where 35% of your energy should go. Opposition zones, where your roots are weak, deserve around 15%: not to win them, but to avoid signalling complete absence and to learn from them. Fifty per cent of your energy should go to strongholds, because an abandoned strength becomes the most vulnerable point — precisely the mistake personally made during the second candidacy in Portici.

How should you respond to a serious event that erupts in the middle of a campaign — an accident or a local tragedy?

The wrong response is to speak as a candidate. The correct response is to speak as a human being. A press release beginning with "As a mayoral candidate, I consider it unacceptable..." instrumentalises someone else’s pain for campaign purposes, and voters always sense it. The sequence that works is this: physical presence on site, listening without cameras, respectful silence during the most acute phase. Only once the hardest moment has passed can the political issue be raised, and then only with restraint. There is, however, a window — usually within the first few hours — in which a human, non-political, non-instrumental word is not only legitimate but necessary. Waiting too long is almost worse than saying nothing at all.

4.7 (7 voti)
Election photography: the portrait that convinces,...
Electoral Design: How Graphic Identity Wins (or Lo...

Related Posts

 

Comments

No comments made yet. Be the first to submit a comment
Already Registered? Login Here
Tuesday, 17 November 2026

By accepting you will be accessing a service provided by a third-party external to https://insightadv.it/

Your weekly dose of Insight!

All our latest work. Every Monday in your inbox.

From Creative Writing to Photography, taking in Marketing and Design along the way. Every day we're busy prepping exclusive content to give you some fresh inspiration. Sign up so you don't miss a thing: every Monday at 09.30am you'll get the full weekly round-up. No spam. Just proper quality content, and you can unsubscribe whenever you like.

 

Satisfied customers

What they say about us

I had the pleasure of collaborating with Umberto, an exquisite person, always available, competent and quick to find solutions to problems, whether large or small; maximum satisfaction!
2013-10-02
Stefano Beltrame
Staff / Nebula Sigarette Digitali
I also leave my testimony regarding the working relationship with Insight Agency, I have been a customer for years now and I am very very satisfied above all for the competence and availability as ...
2013-09-16
Read more
Luca Crocetti
CEO & Co-Founder / Lukkos
I had the opportunity to get to know Insight Agency when he started working with one of our clients, so I was able to appreciate not only their professional and creative approach, but above all the...
2013-09-16
Read more
Mario Gentile
CEO & Founder / Punto Ike

About

Insight Adv Ltd is a full-service advertising agency. We offer our customers Graphic and Web Design, Marketing and Strategic Communication services.

We create websites, e-commerce and fad platforms, commercials and promotional videos and applications for smartphones and tablets. We also offer digital & direct marketing, social media and content management services. 

Pills...

" Advertising agencies express for the collective what dreams express for the individual. "
Marshall McLuhan

Follow us on