24 minutes reading time (4744 words)

Panettone for clients: Caserta deducts it, Manchester doesn't

 Umberto Mazza writing a card by hand next to gift boxes with red ribbon and a stack of card stock

It's a Tuesday at the end of October, and Berto's office, in a warehouse unit on the industrial estate between Santa Maria Capua Vetere and Capua, smells of scorched moka pot and cardboard fresh out of the stockroom. Berto has a printout in front of him. Forty-three names: long-standing clients, suppliers without whom Monday doesn't get going, two or three people who kept his credit open when he needed it.

Next to the printout is a quote from a wine shop: a Christmas hamper at €62 plus VAT. Aglianico, capocollo, honey, an artisan panettone. In Campania, a hamper like that says one thing only: I respect you, now go and eat well at home.

Berto's desk with the list of 43 clients, the Christmas hamper quote and the phone on speaker

The phone, on speaker, crackles. It's the accountant. "Berto, at sixty-two you're over fifty. You can't recover the VAT and the cost counts towards the ceiling on representation expenses. If you want a quiet life, come in under."

Silence. Berto looks at the sheet the way you look at a bill that doesn't add up. I'm sitting opposite him, watching the generosity of a man who built everything with his own hands disappear into a subsection.

A few days later I'm in Salford, in a pub a stone's throw from the canal, at half four on an afternoon when the light has already gone. On the table, sticky with old beer, is an order for cases: local craft beer, £35 a case, for his best clients. Bobby, industrial components, started out of a garage, doesn't look up from his phone.

"I can recover the VAT, Umberto. But I can't deduct it against Corporation Tax: it's alcohol, so as far as HMRC's concerned it's hospitality. To deduct it I'd have to give them a mouse mat with my logo on it this big." He takes a swig. "I'd rather pay the tax than give them some cheap tat."

Umberto and Bobby at a table in a Salford pub, with a case of craft beer on the tableFictional scene generated with artificial intelligence from a photograph of the author.

I've worked between Caserta and London long enough to see the same film shot in two tax languages. In Italy, the fifty-euro threshold changes your route: below it you go straight through, above it you run into a ceiling and you pay the VAT yourself. In the UK it's more brutal. Think of offside: the goal is disallowed for a centimetre, and they don't take away the centimetre. They take away the goal.

But in both cases the real risk isn't the taxman. It's letting your accountant choose your company's tone of voice.

Here's my position, and I'll defend it to the last line: the taxman decides how much you can spend, not what you say. First, though, the rules, spelled out properly, because getting them wrong costs money. Then the cases. Then how to choose.

In a hurry?

  • Italy: up to €50 (on the gift as a whole), it's fully deductible and the VAT is recoverable. Above that, the gift counts towards the ceiling on representation expenses and the VAT can't be recovered.
  • From 2025 payment has to be traceable, even under €50: no cash.
  • United Kingdom: to deduct, you need three things at once: a clearly visible logo on the gift, no food, drink, tobacco or vouchers, and under £50 per person.
  • UK VAT follows different rules: under £50 per person over 12 months, you don't pay output VAT.
  • A hamper with cured meats and cheese won't get into Great Britain the way you'd like it to.
  • On the message inside the gift, the taxman has no say. Only the person receiving it does.

Christmas gifts for clients in Italy: the threshold changes your route

In the Italian system, generosity isn't forbidden. It's channelled. The legislator leaves you a free lane up to a threshold, then makes you change route.

The fifty euros are counted on the whole gift

The number is fifty. If the unit value of the gift doesn't exceed €50, the cost is fully deductible in the year and, a detail the end-of-year roundups skip, it doesn't use up the ceiling on representation expenses. Representation expenses are those incurred to promote the company's image: dinners, events, gifts.

But "unit value" doesn't mean the single product. It means the whole gift. Circular 34/E of 13 July 2009 from the Agenzia delle Entrate (the Italian Revenue Agency) makes this clear precisely for hampers: a hamper with three items at €20 each counts as a single €60 gift, and as such falls outside the fifty-euro regime. The taxman looks at the box, not what's in it.

Some argue that several items packed and delivered separately to the same recipient stay deductible if each one is under fifty. It's a contested reading: before building a strategy on it, get written confirmation from your accountant. And in any case, three parcels on three different days isn't a gift. It's a logistics headache.

Above fifty euros: the ceiling and the sum nobody does

Back to the €62 hamper. Above €50 the gift loses full deductibility and counts towards the ceiling on representation expenses. It doesn't become non-deductible: it becomes deductible within a limit calculated on the revenue from your core business. The ceiling is 1.5% of revenue up to €10 million, then 0.6% on the slice between €10 and €50 million, and 0.4% beyond that. These are bands: each percentage applies only to its own slice. Anything over the ceiling is lost for good, with no carry-forward to later years. And the ceiling covers all of the year's representation expenses, not just gifts.

Let's do Berto's sum. Forty-three hampers at €62 come to €2,666 plus VAT. At 1.5%, they fit in full if revenue is above roughly €178,000 (2,666 divided by 0.015) and there are no other representation expenses. Berto turns over well above that. For him, the ceiling isn't the cage he's been told about.

The real problem is elsewhere, and it's in the VAT.

VAT: the real cost of the sixty-two euros

For goods you buy to give away that aren't part of your own business, the purchase VAT is recoverable only if the unit cost doesn't exceed €50. Above that, it's entirely non-recoverable: it becomes a cost and gets added to the value of the gift. The free transfer, in this case, falls outside the scope of VAT: you don't need to invoice anything.

If instead you give away a product that is part of your own business, the picture changes: you recover the purchase VAT, but the free transfer is normally taxable, as if you'd sold it. If Berto had a pasta factory in Gragnano and gave away his own pasta, this is where he'd land.

So what does it cost in practice? It depends on what's inside, because wine doesn't carry the same rate as panettone. Take Berto's hamper with typical prices, all excluding VAT: aglianico €22, capocollo €18, honey €8, panettone €14. That makes €62. Wine pays 22%; cured meats, honey and sweets pay 10%: that's €8.84 of VAT per hamper, roughly €380 across the forty-three. The accountant will work out the real figure on the real products, but that's the order of magnitude: three hundred and eighty euros against the risk of sending forty-three people a second-best hamper.

Are the €50 counted with or without VAT?

For VAT recovery, the yardstick is the unit purchase cost of the item. For deductibility, the value includes any non-recoverable VAT. A professional presentation from 2014, on the other hand, reads them gross of VAT, and for your own products what counts is the "normal value" (Resolution 27/E of 2014). The readings don't quite line up: ask your accountant how they count it and leave yourself some margin. In Berto's case it makes no difference: €62 plus VAT is over the limit on every reading.

From 2025, no more paying in cash

Here's the change that plenty of end-of-year roundups leave out. The 2025 Budget Law (Law 207/2024, article 1, paragraphs 81-83) made the deductibility of representation expenses, gifts included, conditional on payment by traceable means: bank transfer, debit, credit or prepaid cards, cheques. The rule applies even under €50 and even to purchases made abroad. The Agenzia delle Entrate confirmed it in Circular 15/E of 22 December 2025, and the industry guides for Christmas 2026 treat it as unchanged.

Translation: you can no longer pop down to your trusted deli with two hundred euros in cash and walk out with four hams for your main clients. Without a traceable payment, as far as the taxman's concerned, that cost doesn't exist.

And if you're a professional?

Self-employed professionals have a regime of their own. The ceiling is 1% of fees, and under article 54-septies of the TUIR (the Consolidated Income Tax Act) even gifts under €50 count towards the ceiling, with no full deduction as there is for businesses. The traceable-payment requirement, for them, applies wherever the expenses are incurred, from 18 June 2025 (Decree-Law 84/2025). If you're a professional, the table below isn't yours: ask your adviser.

Corporate gifts in the United Kingdom: a gate with three locks

In Salford the logic is different. There's no road with a ceiling. There's a gate with three locks, and you have to open all of them.

The three locks of Corporation Tax

Corporation Tax is the British tax on company profits. HMRC, the UK's tax authority, treats gifts like business entertainment: non-deductible by default. The exceptions are in the HMRC manual (BIM45070), which refers to section 1300 of the Corporation Tax Act 2009 (for sole traders, to section 47 of ITTOIA 2005), and they must all apply together:

  1. The logo. The gift carries your company's advertising in a clearly visible way. On the gift itself, not just on the wrapping.
  2. The category. It isn't food, drink, tobacco or a voucher exchangeable for goods.
  3. The ceiling. The cost, added to any other gifts to the same person in the period (the tax year for sole traders, the accounting period for companies), doesn't exceed £50.

Examples HMRC treats as acceptable: diaries, pens, mouse mats.

And here's the offside again. Above £50 HMRC doesn't trim the excess: it disallows the whole amount. That's why Bobby, in that Salford pub, is resigned to it. He wanted to give beer. The second lock was shut.

VAT is a different story

VAT, Value Added Tax, is the British equivalent of Italy's IVA, and it doesn't use the same keys. Under VAT Notice 700/7, you don't have to account for output VAT until the total cost of gifts to the same person exceeds £50, excluding VAT, in any 12-month period. Above that figure, if you'd recovered the VAT on the purchase, you have to pay VAT on the cost of all the gifts made to that person. No logo needed. No exclusion for food and drink. If you'd rather avoid the calculation, you can choose not to recover the VAT on purchase: HMRC allows it.

Here's Bobby's trap. One case at £35: VAT recoverable, no output tax. Two cases to the same client within twelve months come to £70, and the VAT has to be paid on the lot. On the very same case of beer, Corporation Tax says no and VAT says yes, up to the limit. It's not two offices disagreeing. It's two taxes with different rules.

The hamper doesn't make it over the border

Let's take another typical case. Berto wants to send a hamper to Bobby, in Manchester: aglianico, capocollo, a piece of cheese, the panettone.

Since 12 April 2025 the British government has extended to all European Union countries the ban on bringing into Great Britain, for personal use, meat from cattle, sheep, goats and pigs, and dairy products, cured meats and cheeses included. Gov.uk describes it as a temporary restriction, to protect against foot-and-mouth disease. Commercial consignments of products of animal origin follow a different route: advance notification, entry through a border control post and, for meat and dairy, a health certificate. For a Christmas hamper, it's a route that's rarely worth the effort.

For the rest of the hamper, wine, baked sweets, pasta, the rules on composite products and duties are technical. Before shipping, ask your freight forwarder and read the official gov.uk pages "Bringing food into Great Britain". Otherwise Berto's gift ends up, come January, as a rejected hamper and a red face with a client.

The comparison in a table

 ItalyUnited Kingdom
Threshold€50 on the total value of the gift£50 per recipient, in the period
Above the thresholdRepresentation expense: deductible within the ceiling on revenue, VAT not recoverableNo deduction: you lose the whole amount
Food and drinkAllowed (the hamper is the classic case)Excluded from deduction. VAT is a separate matter
Logo on the giftIrrelevant: branded gadgets are representation expenses tooMandatory and visible on the gift itself
VATRecoverable only under €50; free transfer outside the scope of VAT (goods that aren't your own)No output VAT up to £50 (excluding VAT) in 12 months per person

Infographic: in Italy the €50 threshold changes your route, in the United Kingdom the gift goes through a gate with three locks

In Italy the rule is a road that narrows: it doesn't stop you giving good food, it just makes life awkward beyond the threshold. In the UK, HMRC doesn't stop you giving panettone: it just refuses the deduction. As if to say: if you want to be generous, do it out of your own margins, not everybody else's taxes.

And this is the point for anyone thinking strategically. If you can't deduct a cost, it stops being a tax operation and becomes a marketing spend. And the question changes: is this relationship worth the full cost of the gift? If so, send the €62 hamper and pay up. If not, don't blame the taxman.

Gifts and anti-bribery: the limit that isn't fiscal

If you think the ceiling is set only by the Agenzia delle Entrate or HMRC, you're looking at half the board. The other half is criminal.

United Kingdom: the offence of "failure to prevent"

The Bribery Act 2010, the British anti-corruption law, doesn't ban hospitality. According to the Ministry of Justice guidance, bona fide, reasonable and proportionate hospitality is allowed. But the law also creates a corporate offence (section 7): if a person working for you pays a bribe to win you a commercial advantage, the company is liable if it didn't have adequate procedures. That's why it's not unusual for the recipient's company to have an internal rule with its own threshold. Bobby could find his case of beer stuck at reception. Ask first.

Italy: if the client is public

The code of conduct for public employees (DPR 62/2013, Decree of the President of the Republic) allows gifts of modest value, set at €150. But the criminal division of the Court of Cassation, in judgment 49524 of 2017, made clear that even a gift below the threshold can amount to corruption if it's used to steer an administrative matter: the case involved meal vouchers and petrol vouchers. If you have a local council among your clients, your problem isn't deductibility.

The practical rule

Three lines that will save you trouble: a written policy, a list of recipients with values and dates, and no gifts while a tender or a case is open.

What the gift says: four brand cases

The cases that follow concern the consumer (B2C, business to consumer), not a business client (B2B, business to business). I use them because a big brand amplifies the mechanics of gift-giving. The lesson lies in the idea, not the budget.

Baci Perugina: the message is the gift

In 1922 Luisa Spagnoli salvages the hazelnut grain that was being thrown away at the factory and makes it into a squat chocolate shaped like a knuckle. She calls it "Cazzotto", meaning "punch". Giovanni Buitoni, her partner, realises nobody will ever walk into a shop and ask for that, and renames it "Bacio", meaning "kiss".

The masterstroke, though, is a slip of paper. The silver and blue wrapper and the little notes with love quotes are the work of Federico Seneca, Perugina's art director. There are two versions of where the idea came from: legend has it that Luisa and Giovanni used to swap hidden messages inside the chocolates; the more prosaic version says Seneca imported the custom from America. I'm telling you both because I don't know which is true, and anyone who guarantees you just one truth is selling something. A 1927 advert claimed that in only five years Perugina had handed out a hundred million Baci.

 Handwritten card tucked under the ribbon of a Christmas hamper

The lesson for Berto is simple, and it stings: the chocolate is the vehicle, the note is the gift. A handwritten card with a line that shows you know the person counts for more than the difference between a capocollo and a salami. I've written about this before, by the way: packaging tells the story before you open your mouth.

John Lewis: selling attention

In the UK the gift has become a national ritual, one advert at a time. For John Lewis, the British department store, Christmas accounts for about 20% of annual sales and 40% of profits. The 2012-2015 campaigns won the Grand Prix at the 2016 IPA Effectiveness Awards (the Institute of Practitioners in Advertising's prizes for advertising effectiveness): Christmas sales up by an average of 16% and over £8 of profit for every pound invested, all built around a single idea, thoughtful giving.

Two caveats. It's a case told by the people who made the campaigns, and it lives on TV budgets that Berto doesn't have. But the idea is very much copyable: people reward care, not the receipt. It's the opposite of the same hamper for forty-three clients.

Ferrero Rocher: the gift you don't control

Ferrero is Italian and in the 1990s, in the UK, it ran the same advert for eight years: a reception at an embassy, a waiter with a tray, a pyramid of chocolates. Made by the company's in-house advertising department, it became, according to Marketing Week, one of the most admired and most loathed campaigns of the period. In the Channel 4 and Sunday Times viewers' poll of the 100 greatest TV adverts, broadcast in April 2000, it came twenty-first. The brief for the next campaign, handed to a London agency, said the chocolates are so special that sometimes it's hard to give them away.

It's not a failure: eight years on air is no accident. It's proof that you can choose the gift, but not how the person receiving it will read it. A hamper with a gold bow, in certain offices, doesn't say "prestige". It says "I was trying to make an impression".

Peloton: the gift that judges

November 2019. Peloton, the American maker of connected exercise bikes, launches the advert "The Gift That Gives Back". A husband gives his wife the bike, though she's already in shape; she films a year of workouts and shows them to him at Christmas. Social media reads it as sexist: a woman monitoring her weight to please her partner. The company replies that it wanted to celebrate a wellness journey. On 3 December the share price drops more than 9% in one session: roughly $942 million of market capitalisation.

It holds for B2B too: a gift always communicates a judgement about the recipient. Don't give anything that presupposes a flaw to be fixed: the book on organising your office, the software for managing your time. What you're telling the client is that you think they're disorganised. With your company's money.

How to localise client gifts: from the Granatello to Shoreditch

Tax theory is about borders; gift-giving practice is about place. Your choices need to be compatible with the rules, but must never turn into stereotypes.

In Campania the local area gives you answers that fit inside fifty euros: bronze-drawn Gragnano pasta, a piece of Vietri sul Mare ceramics, a bit of San Gregorio Armeno craftsmanship, from Naples. Paid for by traceable means, with a card inside. An object with a story says you exist in a physical place and you're not just an IBAN on an invoice.

In London the logic flips. If you want the deduction, the gift is a tool, not an indulgence: a quality diary or a pen, with the logo clearly visible on the item and under £50 per person. If you'd rather go for cheeses from Borough Market, in Southwark, you know what you're doing: you recover the VAT under the threshold and give up the deduction. You do it for positioning, not to save money. I've written elsewhere about how to build a brand that speaks two languages: the same rule applies to gifts.

 Leather diary and pen with a clearly visible geometric logo on a London desk

GiftItalyUnited Kingdom
Hamper with wine and food, under the thresholdDeductible and VAT recoverable (traceable payment, under €50 in total)Not deductible for Corporation Tax. VAT recoverable under £50 per person in 12 months
Diary or pen with logoSame treatment as other gifts: the logo doesn't change the treatmentDeductible if the logo is clearly visible on the item and the total per person stays under £50
Voucher or gift cardSpecific VAT rules: ask your accountantExcluded from deduction (vouchers exchangeable for goods)

There's also the alternative of a donation to a charity in the client's name. It has its own tax regime in each country and, from a relationship point of view, it's colder: it solves the budget, but it doesn't land on the desk.

The five filters before you order

The difference between an investment in relationships and a bonfire of cash isn't decided at the accountant's. It's decided at your desk, at the end of October. Before you sign the quote for forty-three hampers, run the idea through five filters. If it fails one, stop.

 Five steps in sequence: who, what it says, the rules, the timing, the measure

  1. Who. A long-standing client? A prospect to close in January? A key supplier? A public body? Don't use the same yardstick for everyone. Segmenting the list hurts, and it's the part that matters: I talk about it in a guide to customer loyalty, but here the gesture is just the one.
  2. What it says. Does the gift show you know the person? An expensive gift that misses the mark says: I don't know who you are, I just wanted you to see I'd spent money.
  3. The rules. Italy: under €50 in total, traceable payment, a margin on the VAT calculation. United Kingdom: logo on the item, no food or vouchers, under £50. And for everyone: no gifts while a tender is open.
  4. The timing. Order in October, sort out the paperwork in November, deliver in the first half of December, when desks aren't yet piled high with your competitors' gifts. I wrote about the calendar in a guide to Black Friday and planning.
  5. The measure. Don't count parcels. Count replies: how many wrote you a message that wasn't automated, how many called you, how many booked an appointment in January. A gift done well becomes word of mouth.
Action checklist
  • Segment the list: clients, suppliers, public administration.
  • Write next to each name one thing you know about that person.
  • Set the budget with your accountant, asking how they count the €50 in relation to VAT.
  • Pay by traceable means and keep the invoice.
  • United Kingdom: logo on the item, no food, drink or vouchers, under £50 per person.
  • Check whether the recipient has an internal gifts policy.
  • Shipments abroad: ask your freight forwarder what can get through.
  • Write the cards by hand.
Five mistakes to avoid
  • Paying cash at your trusted supplier.
  • Choosing the €62 hamper "to make a good impression" without looking at the VAT.
  • Sending the same hamper to everyone.
  • Giving wine in the UK and expecting the deduction.
  • Sending a gift to someone with a tender or a case open with you.

The real budget, mind, gets decided earlier. If you want to set the figure properly, I've covered it in a guide to marketing budgets for SMEs.

Forty-three cards

A gift trimmed to fit under the threshold is like pasta drained two minutes too early: on the plate it looks the same, but you can tell on the first forkful. The person receiving it notices.

The taxman sets how much you can spend, and he's right to put up a fence. Inside the fence, what you say is up to you. Anyone who chooses a gift purely on the basis of the deduction sends forty-three people the same message: I've done the sums on you, and you're worth €49.90.

Berto knows this. That's why, once the call with the accountant is over, he picks up a pen and starts with the first name on the list. It'll take him a whole afternoon. His hands, used to delivery notes, will write badly. It's the part of the gift that no subsection can tax, limit or deduct.

Choose what you want to say. Accept the tax consequences of where you are. And if you're going to spend, spend to leave a mark. Everything else is just stock.

If you'd like to think through your list before ordering, drop me a line: we can talk it over with a coffee.

Sources and references

Italy

United Kingdom

Brand cases

The images in this article were generated with artificial intelligence tools. The tax guidance is for information only and is no substitute for advice from your accountant or a British tax adviser.

Frequently asked questions

How much can I spend on a Christmas gift for a client in Italy?

Up to €50 of unit value, calculated on the gift as a whole, the cost is fully deductible and the purchase VAT is recoverable for goods that aren't your own. Above that, the gift is a representation expense: deductible within the ceiling on revenue (1.5% up to €10 million) and with non-recoverable VAT. Ask your accountant how to count the VAT within the limit.

Does a Christmas hamper count as a single gift for the €50 limit?

Yes. According to Circular 34/E of 13 July 2009 from the Agenzia delle Entrate, the limit refers to the total value of the package, not the individual products in it: a hamper with three items at €20 is worth €60.

Can I pay for client gifts in cash?

If you want to deduct them, no. From 2025 (from 1 January for companies whose financial year matches the calendar year) representation expenses and gifts are deductible only if paid by traceable means (bank transfer, cards, cheques). It applies even under €50 and to purchases made abroad. For professionals the requirement applies to expenses incurred from 18 June 2025.

What changes for professionals?

For the self-employed the limit is 1% of fees and, under art. 54-septies of the TUIR, even gifts under €50 count towards the ceiling, with no full deduction as there is for businesses. Confirm your case with your accountant.

Can I deduct wine, beer or a food hamper in the UK?

Not for Corporation Tax: food, drink, tobacco and vouchers are excluded. Only gifts with the company logo clearly visible on the item and a total cost under £50 per person in the period are allowed. VAT follows different rules: no output tax up to £50 (excluding VAT) per person in 12 months.

Can I send a hamper with cured meats and cheese to a client in Great Britain?

In practice, no. Since 12 April 2025 meat and dairy from the EU can't come into Great Britain for personal use, and commercial consignments of products of animal origin require advance notification, a border check and, for meat and dairy, a health certificate. For other products, ask your freight forwarder and check the gov.uk pages.

When should I not give a client a gift?

When they're a public body and a tender or a case is open: in Italy DPR 62/2013 sets modest value at €150, but the Court of Cassation has ruled out the lawfulness of below-threshold gifts if they're aimed at a case. In the UK the Bribery Act requires gifts to be reasonable and proportionate. And never give anything that presupposes a judgement about the recipient.

4.8 (4 voti)
Direct Flash: The Flaw That Became a Signature
The House That Empties Out: How a Ghost Story Is B...

Related Posts

 

Comments

No comments made yet. Be the first to submit a comment
Already Registered? Login Here
Tuesday, 17 November 2026

By accepting you will be accessing a service provided by a third-party external to https://insightadv.it/

Your weekly dose of Insight!

All our latest work. Every Monday in your inbox.

From Creative Writing to Photography, taking in Marketing and Design along the way. Every day we're busy prepping exclusive content to give you some fresh inspiration. Sign up so you don't miss a thing: every Monday at 09.30am you'll get the full weekly round-up. No spam. Just proper quality content, and you can unsubscribe whenever you like.

 

Satisfied customers

What they say about us

I had the pleasure of collaborating with Umberto, an exquisite person, always available, competent and quick to find solutions to problems, whether large or small; maximum satisfaction!
2013-10-02
Stefano Beltrame
Staff / Nebula Sigarette Digitali
I also leave my testimony regarding the working relationship with Insight Agency, I have been a customer for years now and I am very very satisfied above all for the competence and availability as ...
2013-09-16
Read more
Luca Crocetti
CEO & Co-Founder / Lukkos
I had the opportunity to get to know Insight Agency when he started working with one of our clients, so I was able to appreciate not only their professional and creative approach, but above all the...
2013-09-16
Read more
Mario Gentile
CEO & Founder / Punto Ike

About

Insight Adv Ltd is a full-service advertising agency. We offer our customers Graphic and Web Design, Marketing and Strategic Communication services.

We create websites, e-commerce and fad platforms, commercials and promotional videos and applications for smartphones and tablets. We also offer digital & direct marketing, social media and content management services. 

Pills...

" Advertising agencies express for the collective what dreams express for the individual. "
Marshall McLuhan

Follow us on